Willness: Building VRA Fertility Zones on Plant Biomass Alone is Short-Sighted

I posed a question in a twitter poll in order to raise awareness of how measurements of biomass from remote sensing have major limitations in a soil applied variable-rate fertilizer program. 324 voters participated.

The correct answer? D. There is not enough information collected to provide the correct answer for this.

This is why I conducted the poll. 90% of respondents answered A, B or C. It is my opinion, as this poll demonstrates, that most people do not understand that looking at biomass alone is NOT enough information to decide if an area needs low rates or high rates of fertilizer.

Why? Let’s explore the two main issues:

  1. Biomass alone without soil testing (checking the fridge) does not work. There are companies that do this. They sample no zones, or maybe just the field average zone, or maybe do all zones every 3 years. If you don’t know what is in the fridge, you don’t know if the zone will need groceries. For mobile nutrients like nitrogen and sulfur, they can vary a lot from year to year. Furthermore, taking biomass alone and turning it into zones doesn’t work. Why? Because a biomass area is not consistent with fertilizer response as discussed below.

2. Biomass alone as a predictor of fertilizer response does not work.

Willness: “On this BAY MAPS image (left) you can clearly see it puts the eroded, thin topsoil, dry hills as the same biomass as the wet, saline depressions. BAY is “correlated imagery” in this example. On the right is SWAT, which is our patented soil, water and topography modeling done by field soil surveys.” (Maps Submitted by Cory Willness) 

Scenario 1: Low biomass (skinny): yields will be lower…something is wrong…what is the cause?

Fridge full — The areas could have very high fertility levels but still be skinny due to disease, insects, salinity, weed issues, too wet, or have a single nutrient deficiency. Low biomass areas may not have spatial consistency, in fact they could be opposites. Hills may have high biomass in wet years and low biomass in dry years. In most cases, the reason for low biomass is something other than fertility. This is why all low biomass areas should not be sampled as a zone – they could be low for many different reasons. If a skinny person went to a doctor how likely is it that they are skinny because their fridge is empty? Most likely it is because of a different health problem.

Fridge empty — Areas may just need a better overall fertility program. A low biomass area may benefit from more fertility if it is an eroded hill that is lower in organic matter and thin topsoil. In conditions with ample moisture, they could be some of the highest responders to fertilizer in the field. If the skinny person has the right amount of water, has no health issue, and their fridge is empty then they need groceries.

Takeaway: In the low biomass areas the fridge can be full or empty.

Scenario 2: Very high biomass (obese): excess vegetation…lodging…disease…yields may suffer.

Fridge full — These areas could be an old yard site, new breaking, old pastures, areas collecting eroded soil such as depressions or old fence lines. These are examples where you would expect high mineralization potential and very low fertilizer response. They will have very high biomass due to high organic levels and high soil test levels of nutrients. If you are obese and your fridge is full you do not need groceries.

Fridge empty — Good examples of very high biomass areas with overall low fertility levels are not as common. Peat soils typically have high biomass due to high organic levels and excess N mineralization but often show up deficient in potassium and copper. In this case you need high rates of specific fertilizers only, but they are high biomass areas that require a lot of it to correct the issue.

Scenario 3: High biomass (muscular): everything is just right in the consistently high producing areas.

Fridge full — A well drained depression that is very high in organic matter and 2 feet thick topsoil can mineralize a lot of nitrogen and contain a lot of nutrients. It would turn obese if you put a lot of fertilizer there. It does not require extremely high rates of fertilizer to attain excellent yields.

Fridge empty — It is common that the highest biomass areas could be midslope and field average soils producing consistently high yields every year – never too wet or too dry. They can often have the lowest soil test levels of nutrients in the field because of this consistently high productivity. These areas may require the highest fertilizer rates in the field, being mined of nutrients in the past. However, hills in wet years with thin topsoil, low organic matter, and do not contain a lot of nutrients will require a lot of fertilizer to produce the high end yields they are capable of. In wet years these hills can produce excellent crops if fertilized aggressively. In the wet years of 2010 and 2011 hills were the high biomass areas in most of our fields. Depressions could be the exact opposite. As mentioned already, spatial consistency from dry to wet years can be inconsistent.

Takeaway: In the top performing areas the fridge can be full or empty.

Author Summary:

Are low biomass areas a fertility zone?

No. They can have poor fertility or high fertility.

Should all low biomass areas be treated the same?

No. The areas of low biomass are typically not low for the same reasons, some may require no fertilizer and some may require high rates of fertilizer. This exact question can be posed for all sizes of biomass and you will get the same answer. You cannot deliver groceries to homes and drop them off based on the body type that answers the door. Each body type can have a full or empty fridge.

The dominant zone mapping process in the variable-rate industry is what? Biomass. Using biomass to make zones, soil sampling the biomass zones, recommending fertilizer rates for prescriptions based on biomass zones.

Is biomass a good foundation to make zones?

No. As my examples suggest, biomass does not have a good relationship with fertility requirements. So why is it the dominant zone process then? It is quick, easy, and scalable. There are probably 100 software platforms you can purchase to use biomass to build zones, so that is what people do if they don’t know any different.

But is it the foundation of a solid variable-rate zone building, soil sampling, and prescription application for application of soil applied fertilizer?

Not for me.

RELATED CONTENT: January 2018 PrecisionAg® Professional profile on Cory Willness and his CropPro Consulting outfit. 

Leave a Reply

Americas Stories
AmericasOn The Scene: 2018 Farm Progress Show Wrap Up
September 5, 2018
Former Monsanto President (now Bayer CropScience Chief Operating Office) Brett Begemann’s opening salvo during his first appearance at a Farm Read More
AmericasStrider, Syngenta and Trends in Digital Agriculture
September 5, 2018
I recently attended Strider Day in São Paulo, an event hosted by Brazilian agtech company Strider. The event offered two Read More
John Deere ExactApply
AmericasSciFi in Ag: Self-Reacting Spray Nozzles to Fight Dicamba Drift
September 5, 2018
Article Notes: This monthly column takes some crazy sounding ideas and applies them to the field of Ag Tech. The Read More
AmericasNutrien Ag Solutions Lumsden: Pursuing Precision on Canada’s Vast Western Prairie
August 23, 2018
I think it’s safe to say we’re pretty obsessed with adoption in this industry, aren’t we? Whether it be on Read More
Trending Articles
Data ManagementAre You Using Your Soil to Its Full Potential?
September 14, 2018
Harvest is progressing across most parts of the U.S. and those growers who aren’t already harvesting are gearing up to Read More
Imagery/SensingAgtech: 10 Things I Hate About You!
September 4, 2018
Before you get bent out of shape from the title, remember if you’ve read my articles before you know I Read More
Kansas State University
Industry NewsKansas State University, Topcon Form Precision Ag Research Partnership
August 30, 2018
Kansas State University and Topcon Agriculture are collaborating to develop tools and systems to advance precision agriculture and support farmers. Read More
Blockchain building block graphic
Specialty CropsIs Blockchain the Future of Food Safety?
August 24, 2018
When the Internet Protocol Suite (TCP/IP) was standardized in 1982, permitting the worldwide proliferation of interconnected networks and eventually the Read More
WinField’s Joel Wipperfurth On Empowering Data-Driven Decisions
InfoAg ConferenceOne on One with Joel Wipperfurth, Winfield United
August 15, 2018
Winfield United's Joel Wipperfurth discusses ag technology trends and topics during last month’s InfoAg Conference. Read More
Industry NewsUrtheCast to Acquire Geosys from Land O’Lakes in $20 Million Deal
August 15, 2018
UrtheCast Corp. and Land O’Lakes, Inc. today announced they have entered a binding term sheet for the purchase of Geosys Read More
Latest News
Business ManagementIvy Tech, Farmers Partner to Help Precision Ag Educatio…
September 20, 2018
Harvest time has taken on a new meaning for some Wabash Valley farmers, and Bobbi Hunt-Kincaid hopes her family’s first Read More
Sensors/IoTThe Answer to Agriculture’s Daunting Challenges – Soil …
September 20, 2018
According to the United Nations, 9.6 billion people will live on planet Earth by 2050. Feeding these mouths will require Read More
Data ManagementRainfall Revisited: Accurate Observations and Beyond
September 18, 2018
As a provider of weather analysis and forecast services to the agricultural industry, one of the most common questions I Read More
Business ManagementWhy Is Funding a Challenge for Women-Led Agtech Compani…
September 17, 2018
When it comes to women-led agtech companies the funding discussion never seems to cease. In June after the The New Read More
Mobile Phone in field
Decision Support SoftwareWhy Are 570 Million Farmers Not Yet Using Agricultural …
September 17, 2018
Until recently, using agricultural apps and software was a rare practice among growers. This is now changing. The mass adoption Read More
Data ManagementAre You Using Your Soil to Its Full Potential?
September 14, 2018
Harvest is progressing across most parts of the U.S. and those growers who aren’t already harvesting are gearing up to Read More
Grower Services & SolutionsDeere-Granular Collaboration Produces New Profit Maps T…
September 14, 2018
The newest development from the ongoing John Deere-Granular product development and marketing collaboration is Profit Maps, now available to farmers Read More
DronesOpinion: Combining Two Pluses with the WingtraOne UAV
September 13, 2018
For the every-day consumer interested in UAVs, there is an ocean of products from which to choose. This includes the Read More
AsiaShould Agri-Input Manufacturers Outsource E-Commerce to…
September 12, 2018
Editor’s note: Venky Ramachandran is a contributing writer for PrecisionAg.com’s sister site, AgriBusinessGlobal.com. This article was originally published on LinkedIn. Now, Read More
Industry NewsValley Irrigation Adds Remote Irrigation Management Opt…
September 11, 2018
Valley Irrigation, an industry leader in smart irrigation solutions, has announced enhancements to its remote management technologies. Multi-Year Licensing In Read More
Variable Rate ApplicationVariable Rate Fertigation System Expands with Mobile Co…
September 10, 2018
Building on the success of its Reflex Variable Rate Fertigation system, Agri-Inject has taken fluid injection to the next level Read More
Industry NewsTeralytic Earns Ag Data Transparent Certification
September 10, 2018
Soil analytics company Teralytic has completed the Ag Data Transparent certification, affirming that their data use is private, secure, and Read More
Business ManagementTop 20 Two-Year Colleges for Precision Agriculture
September 10, 2018
Earlier this year, I compiled a list of the 25 best colleges for precision agriculture. It was quite the process. Read More
Industry NewsRaven, Topcon Announce Slingshot API Agreement
September 6, 2018
Raven Industries and Topcon Agriculture announced today a licensing agreement for Topcon Agriculture’s use of the Slingshot Application Programming Interface Read More
Tablet Grower
Data ManagementThe Power of Predictive Analytics in Agriculture
September 5, 2018
Years ago if we would have been told computers, data, and technology would be scattered around every farm there may Read More
DronessenseFly Launches eBee X Drone, Breaks Through 1,000 ac…
September 5, 2018
senseFly today reportedly sets a new standard in mapping tools with the launch of the eBee X. Launched with the Read More
AmericasOn The Scene: 2018 Farm Progress Show Wrap Up
September 5, 2018
Former Monsanto President (now Bayer CropScience Chief Operating Office) Brett Begemann’s opening salvo during his first appearance at a Farm Read More
EventsAg Experts Discuss Big Data Challenges in Agriculture
September 5, 2018
Agricultural experts at a Houston conference praised the advancements in unmanned aerial vehicles, sensors, and data-collecting technology used in precision Read More