Advancing Precision Programs: One Agronomist’s Perspective

Despite industry concerns that 2014 could bring a downturn in precision use with the lower overall outlook for commodity crop prices, Bill Aiken says that there is a considerable level of optimism among their grower members.

Aiken is precision agronomy lead at Stateline Cooperative, Burt, IA, and he has been working on the conundrum of building a successful precision program for many years at different retail organizations. His charge at Stateline, where he started last fall, is to help redefine precision farming and help nudge along the adoption process.

“What the leadership and the board of Stateline have challenged me to do is to examine our definition of precision agriculture and precision farming,” says Aiken. The main reason, he says, is because the early definition of precision farming has been misleading. “At a 30,000-foot view, many growers still have the perception that if they implement precision ag technology that they will cut input costs.” Growers who view this as the end game will tell you that they believe they are paying Cadillac prices for a Chevrolet product.

“We have found out that the reduction in input cost is not one-size-fits-all and predictable, nor should it be the driver of change. Optimizing production inputs, in a manner that enhances profitability while having a neutral environmental impact appeals more to us than merely reducing input costs. It requires a tremendous amount of due diligence amongst trusted advisors to determine if it is even viable,” he adds. Even the “bleeding edge” category – those willing to try new things even without a definitive return on investment, are going to expect sound, tested science based programs, or well-designed “On Farm Discovery” projects with an opportunity to minimize risk long term.

There is another factor, too. Some service providers have also leaned too heavily on the sale of components to drive profitability in precision programs as well, says Aiken. With few exceptions, precision has not evolved far enough beyond “component management” – selling individual products or components of a precision program, such as variable rate seed or fertilizer, and data analysis, rather than a cohesive program. “It has evolved that way because it can generate cash flow, but in the end it can be disruptive to a full program approach because we end up talking about the tools and not the toolbox,” he adds.

Like many cooperatives that have emerged from consolidation, acquisitions, and expansion over the past decade, Stateline is a collaboration of eight independents and local coops. With different dynamics in each place, precision programs will need to be fluid and flexible to address each situation. And, growers across the strata of experience with precision will need to be able to understand the benefits.

“If it’s a leading edge grower, the top one-third of the marketplace, he will generally be willing to invest an extra dollar with a questionable return. But the next two segments, the early adopters and what I call the “tell me” (late adopters) segments that make up the remaining two-thirds, are not going to invest a dime unless you can tie some predictability to it. Our job is to provide ‘equity’ regardless of segments and address viable ROI to both the grower and retail.”

One of Aiken’s first exercises in the redefinition of Stateline’s precision program was to go out and survey growers, retail managers and agronomists, consultants and academia in the area to identify barriers, roadblocks and opportunities.  “If I could summarize where things have evolved among growers, it’s with a phrase I have adopted: Autopsy Ag,” he explains. “That is, basically many of the decisions we are making for this year are based on post mortem analysis.”

Aiken terms Stateline’s desire is headed to “predictable production.” Working with a deeply involved trusted adviser, the entire toolbox, using applied research and localized on-farm discovery, growers will be able to buy into precision programs that provide a holistic approach to crop production that is tailored to his specific crops, fields, and goals. “We are not completely sure where it will take us, but our main message is that we are going to deal in predictable production and complete, cohesive programs,” says Aiken.

Changing approach is absolutely necessary in order to bring hesitant growers to the table. Aiken pointed out that adoption numbers among retailers, as reported in the CropLife magazine/Purdue University Retail Precision Adoption Survey, have essentially flatlined since 2008. “I think it’s a lack of confidence in precision programs that has left that bar unchanged,” he says.  “Our industry has and is rethinking the message relative to precision ag, but then we need to effectively ‘manage the message.’”

Leave a Reply

Data Stories
Precision Farming
BusinessJanzen: Ag Data Use Policies Are Good for Farmers
August 23, 2016
A number of ag tech companies have developed ag data use policies. Others are working on these. This is a Read More
Farming in Australia
BusinessQ&A: Crop Protection Industry Vet Makes the Precision Leap
August 22, 2016
Simply put, as editors we tend to receive a TON of advertiser-generated press releases between our dual-roles publishing both CropLife.com Read More
Farmer and laptop
DataFarmers Decide How To Share Wealth Of Precision Ag Data
August 18, 2016
To share or not to share? For farmers working in a world of data management, that is the question, writes Read More
DataAgGateway Chair: Precision Ag Entering ‘A New Era For Solutions’
August 18, 2016
New standards, models and other resources to help growers more easily manage their field data have been introduced by AgGateway, Read More
Trending Articles
Ag Drone
Technology10 Bold Predictions For Precision Agriculture
August 11, 2016
The future of technology in agriculture has never looked brighter, or more confusing than it does in 2016. We at Read More
AgPartners
Excellence AwardsAg Partners Honored With 2016 Crop Adviser/Entrepreneur Award
August 2, 2016
Editor’s Note: The PrecisionAg Awards of Excellence program honored the class of 2016 winners during the InfoAg Conference. This year’s winners include Read More
Vision ConferenceLeading Ag Organizations Support First-Ever PrecisionAg Vision Conference
July 27, 2016
The Coalition to Advance Precision Agriculture (CAPA), comprised of trade associations and organizations representing a diverse range of sectors within the Read More
EventsSix Reasons Senior Executives Must Attend The First-Ever PrecisionAg Vision Conference
July 11, 2016
As I made a West Coast swing this spring to visit companies including The Climate Corp. and Planet Labs, there Read More
EventsPrecisionAg® Media Welcomes “Big Data MBA” author William Schmarzo To The Vision Conference Speaker Lineup
June 24, 2016
The PrecisionAg® Vision Conference will feature high-powered and thought-provoking speakers that will bring new perspective to the challenges and opportunities Read More
EventsPrecisionAg® Vision Conference To Feature Kickoff Presenter Kenneth Zuckerberg
June 24, 2016
PrecisionAg® Media is proud to welcome Kenneth Zuckerberg as the kickoff speaker at the inaugural PrecisionAg Vision Conference, October 18-20, 2016 Read More
Latest News
Precision Farming
BusinessJanzen: Ag Data Use Policies Are Good for Farmers
August 23, 2016
A number of ag tech companies have developed ag data use policies. Others are working on these. This is a Read More
Farming in Australia
BusinessQ&A: Crop Protection Industry Vet Makes the Precisi…
August 22, 2016
Simply put, as editors we tend to receive a TON of advertiser-generated press releases between our dual-roles publishing both CropLife.com Read More
AGCO Fuse Ecosystem
SuppliersAGCO Collaborates With Other Industry Leaders To Bring …
August 19, 2016
AGCO Corp. continues to expand its open approach to precision farming through new data connections and industry alliances to provide Read More
GrowersFarmers Find New Ways To Profit With Precision Ag
August 19, 2016
Steve Cubbage has seen that precision agriculture use has been closely tied to farmers’ ability to see a profit from Read More
Veris soil sampling
SuppliersVeris Technologies, The Climate Corp. Form Soil Mapping…
August 19, 2016
Veris Technologies and The Climate Corp., a subsidiary of Monsanto Co., recently announced a partnership that will make high resolution Read More
Farmer and laptop
DataFarmers Decide How To Share Wealth Of Precision Ag Data
August 18, 2016
To share or not to share? For farmers working in a world of data management, that is the question, writes Read More
DataAgGateway Chair: Precision Ag Entering ‘A New Era…
August 18, 2016
New standards, models and other resources to help growers more easily manage their field data have been introduced by AgGateway, Read More
SuppliersTrimble Tacks on 4 New Vantage Partners
August 18, 2016
Trimble announced today that it has added four new partners to its Vantage distribution network — a global network of Read More
BusinessCanadian Drone Startup Lands 2 Deere Dealerships in Dat…
August 18, 2016
Green Aero Tech, a Canadian-based drone imagery provider, has just struck a deal to provide data to two of the Read More
senseFLY’s eBee UAV
ComputerssenseFly, Mobile App Developer Launch Drone Awareness S…
August 18, 2016
Professional drone maker, senseFly, has teamed up with the popular aviation navigation app, Air Navigation Pro, to launch Safer Together. Read More
BusinessDuPont Pioneer Dives Into CRISPR Research
August 17, 2016
DuPont Pioneer researchers are reporting the results of scientific studies demonstrating the potential of CRISPR-Cas as an advanced plant breeding Read More
SDWG Bret Weisenburger
IntegratorsThe Top 10 People In Precision Agriculture
August 15, 2016
Precision agriculture — with all its wacky technologies and advanced algorithms and such — remains a people business. So, without Read More
Robotics AGCO Fendt Guide Connect
TechnologyTop 10 Technologies In Precision Agriculture Right Now
August 12, 2016
Many media companies regularly rank their favorite or most important developments for the past year in various Top 10 lists Read More
Ag Drone
Technology10 Bold Predictions For Precision Agriculture
August 11, 2016
The future of technology in agriculture has never looked brighter, or more confusing than it does in 2016. We at Read More
Buhler-Versatile HQ cab
DataAn Analytic Perspective In Precision Agriculture
August 11, 2016
There is a fascinating depiction of the human body from the perspective of how the brain senses touch. The body Read More
ASMARK Retailers Live! Tour 2016, MAGIE
BusinessAttorney: 5 Things Every Silicon Valley Startup Should …
August 10, 2016
For nearly the last 100 years, agriculture has witnessed only consolidation. This has been true across the board, from machinery Read More
BusinessSRI International Launches Abundant Robotics
August 10, 2016
SRI International today announced the spin-out and launch of Abundant Robotics, an agriculture technology company focused on helping make nutritious Read More
Farmers Edge Truck
DataFormer Syngenta Executive Joins Farmers Edge In Austral…
August 10, 2016
Farmers Edge, a global leader in precision agriculture and independent data management solutions, has announced the appointment of Scott McKinnon Read More