Monsanto’s Plan Puts Focus On Data

PERSPECTIVE  I recently returned from the Agricultural Retailers Association Annual Conference in San Diego where, in addition to the usual networking, I got to host a modest roundtable of ag retailers to talk about the issues of the day. If you’re a grower reading this, hang in there … this is for you too.

The discussion eventually got around to technology, and toward two topics in particular. The first was a question I had: Do retailers feel that Monsanto’s Integrated Farming System, a program that is designed to turn grower planting and harvest data into yield-enhancing hybrid and variety recommendations that growers will pay for, will be a threat to their own precision/agronomy services business?

In general, the retailers around the table, virtually all with pretty robust agronomy services programs in place, did not feel particularly threatened by the service. The concept of providing a “black box” solution is an inherent problem for retail agronomists who believe in and sell the concept that “all agronomy is local,” but none felt it would threaten to displace them.

On the other hand, one participant who is working with Monsanto on IFS felt it might be beneficial to have that recommendation on the table each spring. Part of the issue is that for many (although not everyone), plant population is a relatively new science that few feel they have a strong handle on. And it’s tough to argue that the seed company knows less than anyone else about the seed they sell.

Some retailers were more concerned about the effect on their seed business – the rigorous training requirements Monsanto places on retail agronomists who facilitate the IFS program, and the relatively low return on that training and people investment were at the top of the list. The pilot program rolling out in 2013 will be an interesting test of Monsanto’s approach we will all be watching carefully.

But this led to an even more interesting discussion about something deeper: grower data. Of course, for Monsanto’s program to be successful it will need its growers to provide a lot of field data so recommendations are as on target as possible. Will most growers be willing to submit data to Monsanto? If the past is prologue, we need only turn to Roundup Ready crops. It would have been hard to imagine in the year 2000 that it would take less than a decade for Roundup Ready corn and soybeans to dominate more than 90% of the corn and soybean markets. But the clear value, and the need to be competitive, overcame objections about a company that had not courted the growers’ favor in those early marketing years.

That’s a pretty … no, actually a VERY high value bar that Monsanto set, and one that will be virtually impossible to match through seed selection and plant population recommendations. The cost will have to be carefully set, and the rewards reasonably reliable for growers to buy in. But given the value of a bushel of corn or soybeans it doesn’t take much … at least not as much as it used to.

But getting back to the data: my questions to you all are, who owns this information, and how do you feel about the Monsanto plan? I think it’s clear that the grower owns the raw information he or she collects through soil sampling, planting, inputs and harvest, but what happens when a third party turns this information into an actionable plan? Or uses it in aggregate both to improve the robustness of its recommendations AND to generate more revenue?

Relative to the total population of American farmers, this has happened for years on a relatively small scale with early precision agriculture adopters. Retail agronomists and consultants, and some software companies have been doing this for years with the consent of growers who have embraced the benefits that data processing and aggregation can provide. But Monsanto’s entry into the market will open this up to millions of growers who may not have considered the question of data ownership … including those who have considered it and don’t like the idea of sharing.

As I said, this coming year will be one to watch and listen. By this time next year, we’ll have a much clearer picture of where IFS will be going, and how growers are feeling about it. My feeling is that this will be a bumpy road, as Monsanto delivers its value message, growers weigh it up, and retailers and consultants work to maintain their place as the local agronomy experts.

Topics:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Data Stories
A Satshot NDVIR analysis running on an iPad.
BusinessSatshot’s Landscout IOS Now API Linked With John Deere Operations Center
September 28, 2016
Satshot’s Landscout IOS mobile software is now connected with the John Deere Operations Center through John Deere’s API services. Landscout Read More
Ag Drone
BusinessDroneDeploy Launches Turbo Uploader
September 27, 2016
DroneDeploy today announced a new solution that addresses drone data portability challenges in remote areas that have Internet bandwidth constraints. Read More
FUSE Farm Graphic
DataAGCO Is Founding Member Of The DKE Data-Hub Initiative
September 26, 2016
AGCO Corp., a world-leading manufacturer and distributor of agricultural equipment, has announced its participation as a founding member of the DKE Read More
BusinessADAPT Conversion Toolkit Making In Roads With Equipment Manufacturers
September 22, 2016
A leading group of equipment manufacturers will soon release products that greatly enhance a grower’s ability to manage data across Read More
Trending Articles
Business2016 Farm Science Review: Talkin’ New Products, Education and Big Data
September 21, 2016
The Ohio State University’s Farm Science Review has become an annual rite of fall for Buckeye State growers, retailers and Read More
Mitchell Technical Institute students with drone
IntegratorsMTI Precision Ag Students Use Drone Technology
September 19, 2016
After weeks of sitting in the classroom, several Mitchell Technical Institute students were able to spend a few hours outside Read More
Robotics AGCO Fendt Guide Connect
Market ImpactReport: Ag Robots And Drones May Be A $10 Billion Market By 2022
September 7, 2016
Robots and drones have begun to quietly transform many aspects of agriculture. In fact, the IDTechEx Research report on Agricultural Read More
SDWG Bret Weisenburger
BusinessMZB Technologies, Climate FieldView Announce Data Integration for 2017 Season
September 6, 2016
MZB Technologies announces a data connectivity agreement with The Climate Corporation, a subsidiary of Monsanto Co., providing increased precision agriculture Read More
Deere R4023 cab
BusinessReport: Smart Agriculture Market Worth $19 Billion By 2021
September 6, 2016
Research and Markets has announced the addition of the “Smart Agriculture Market – With Forecast (2016-2021)” report to their offering. Read More
SDWG Bret Weisenburger
IntegratorsThe Top 10 People In Precision Agriculture
August 15, 2016
Precision agriculture — with all its wacky technologies and advanced algorithms and such — remains a people business. So, without Read More
Latest News
A Satshot NDVIR analysis running on an iPad.
BusinessSatshot’s Landscout IOS Now API Linked With John …
September 28, 2016
Satshot’s Landscout IOS mobile software is now connected with the John Deere Operations Center through John Deere’s API services. Landscout Read More
Ag Drone
BusinessDroneDeploy Launches Turbo Uploader
September 27, 2016
DroneDeploy today announced a new solution that addresses drone data portability challenges in remote areas that have Internet bandwidth constraints. Read More
FUSE Farm Graphic
DataAGCO Is Founding Member Of The DKE Data-Hub Initiative
September 26, 2016
AGCO Corp., a world-leading manufacturer and distributor of agricultural equipment, has announced its participation as a founding member of the DKE Read More
Ian Yule, ISPA
ResearchLeading Ag Technology Researcher Appointed ISPA Preside…
September 26, 2016
Massey University’s Professor Ian Yule, one of the world’s leading agri-tech researchers, has been voted president of the International Society Read More
BusinessADAPT Conversion Toolkit Making In Roads With Equipment…
September 22, 2016
A leading group of equipment manufacturers will soon release products that greatly enhance a grower’s ability to manage data across Read More
Business2016 Farm Science Review: Talkin’ New Products, Educati…
September 21, 2016
The Ohio State University’s Farm Science Review has become an annual rite of fall for Buckeye State growers, retailers and Read More
Farmers Edge Truck
DataFarmers Edge Awarded $6.1M Investment From Sustainable …
September 21, 2016
Farmers Edge, a global leader in precision agriculture and independent data management solutions, has announced that it will receive $6,107,563 Read More
BusinessGMO Aphids to Battle Weeds? It’s Not as Far Fetch…
September 21, 2016
No, I am not talking about optimizing aphids for a global agricultural armageddon. That would be silly. I’m talking about Read More
Young Corn Field
Best PracticesNitrogen: The Key to Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions
September 20, 2016
Precision ag can play a key role in reducing agriculture’s impact on greenhouse gases by limiting the nitrogen rate. Read More
W. Wade Robey, Raven
Industry NewsRaven Adds New Director Of Engineering
September 19, 2016
W. Wade Robey, Ph.D., joined Raven Applied Technology in August 2016 as Director of Engineering. In this role, he leads Read More
Mitchell Technical Institute students with drone
IntegratorsMTI Precision Ag Students Use Drone Technology
September 19, 2016
After weeks of sitting in the classroom, several Mitchell Technical Institute students were able to spend a few hours outside Read More
BusinessOPINION: Climate Corp. is the Jewel in Bayer’s Monsanto…
September 15, 2016
PERSPECTIVE: Over the next few days and weeks in the ag media space the major players will examine this latest Read More
Sugarcane India
Market ImpactPlantations International Brings Precision Farming Tech…
September 14, 2016
Hong Kong-based plantation and farm management company Plantations International has announced it is moving its contact centre from the Indian Read More
Corn close up
Start-UpsLewis & Clark Ventures Raises $20 Million For Agric…
September 13, 2016
Lewis & Clark Ventures, a venture capital firm focused on Series A and B stage investments, has announced $20 million Read More
BusinessSentera Joins Forces With Another Drone Distributor
September 13, 2016
Sentera has signed an exclusive distribution agreement with Dynamic UAV Solutions North America, LLC, a new distributor in the commercial Read More
New Zealand agriculture
Market ImpactPrecision Ag Technology Helping New Zealand Agriculture…
September 12, 2016
New Zealand has an enormous opportunity to use technology as a means to support the economic growth of its agri Read More
Robotics AGCO Fendt Guide Connect
Market ImpactReport: Ag Robots And Drones May Be A $10 Billion Marke…
September 7, 2016
Robots and drones have begun to quietly transform many aspects of agriculture. In fact, the IDTechEx Research report on Agricultural Read More
EventsPrecisionAg Vision Conference: Find Your Future in Phoe…
September 7, 2016
As the summer winds down and harvest begins in earnest, the time for immersing ourselves in future planning is getting Read More