Why VRA Fertilizer Is Still A Tough Sell

Variable Rate Application of Fertilizer

Precision agriculture was built on a foundation of variable rate application fertilizer. In the mid-1980s, early personal computer technology and radar-based GPS were employed to demonstrate the concept of map-based VRA which, while economically not viable at the time, proved it would work.

So it’s a bit ironic that nearly 30 years later, the industry has not more fully embraced the technology at the farm level. That said, there are plenty of rational reasons why it’s not more generally accepted among the farming community.

First off, the benefits of VRA are not enjoyed evenly across all fields. Karen Scanlon of the Conservation Technology Information Center says that return on investment from VRA phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) is easiest to demonstrate when soil variability is high.

“The grower gets a higher ROI if the field contains significant high areas and low areas — that is, if there is large variability of soil types in a field,” says Scanlon. “A field with fairly uniform P and K levels has less need for variable rate applications. P and K are usually not yield limiting unless there are very low areas.”

A general lack of understanding, some fear and a dose of skepticism about  adopting the technology also keeps farmers away, says Brent Weisenburger, who coordinates the precision agriculture progam at cooperative South Dakota Wheat Growers.

“I feel growers have held back because they are afraid of the learning curve to get involved, says Weisenburger. “Depending on the level of service delivered by providers in the area, they may not have local expertise to even help them get going in the right direction. They may feel it’s easier to fall back on traditional applications methods than dealing with all of the “technology.”

Weisenburger says that about 30% of the acreage SDWG services uses VRA, and it requires superior service and a “turnkey” solution approach to entice growers to user the service.

Dave Coppess of Heartland Coop in West Des Moines, IA says that growth of VRA has been continuous but exceedingly slow — about 11% of customers are ona a four-year grids sampling program with the cooperative.

“Most of these acres are also provided with variable rate nutrient recommendations, but our goal would be to have 25% to 30% of the acres enrolled in this process.”

Coppess says there’s still an issue with “traditional” farmers simply not wanting to change their ways, and at the current level of profitability that exists, having conversations about changing agronomic course is a difficult. And often, the recommendations that come from a sampling and VRA plan challenge the intuition and experience of the farmer.

On the business side, Coppess says demonstrating a clear payback is a definitely a roadblock. Also, costly upgrades to application equipment may cause both farmers and retailers to balk at making a significant change.

“Equipment limitations and cost factors are certainly part of the equation,” agrees Scanlon. “If a grower has to upgrade a planter or fertilizer delivery system to adopt variable rate application, cost becomes a factor.”

Finally, acquiring the data layers necessary to generate a valuable VRA recommendation is also a limiting factor, adds Scanlon.

Leave a Reply

8 comments on “Why VRA Fertilizer Is Still A Tough Sell

  1. We apply all fertilizer (including nitrogen) using VRT applications. We soil sample and test annually. This is the very best there is.

  2. We apply all fertilizer (including nitrogen) using VRT applications. We soil sample and test annually. This is the very best there is.

  3. There are other considerations like these 2 reports… Stream Nutrient Reductions from Conservation Practices Not Consistently Detectable Across U.S. Released: 10/23/2012 9:00:00 AM Estimation of Nutrient and Sediment Loading in the Mississippi River and Great Lakes Basins with Regional SPARROW Models Throughout the country, declining water quality in rivers and streams has been linked to excessive inputs of nutrients, particularly nitrogen and phosphorus. Nutrient over-enrichment in streams and rivers can lead to eutrophication in downstream waterbodies, causing hypoxia and threatening fish and other aquatic animals. These problems can arise both locally and regionally; for example, one of the principal causes for the increasing size of the Gulf of Mexico hypoxic zone is believed to be the increasing supply of nitrogen delivered to the Gulf from the Mississippi River Basin.

  4. There are other considerations like these 2 reports… Stream Nutrient Reductions from Conservation Practices Not Consistently Detectable Across U.S. Released: 10/23/2012 9:00:00 AM Estimation of Nutrient and Sediment Loading in the Mississippi River and Great Lakes Basins with Regional SPARROW Models Throughout the country, declining water quality in rivers and streams has been linked to excessive inputs of nutrients, particularly nitrogen and phosphorus. Nutrient over-enrichment in streams and rivers can lead to eutrophication in downstream waterbodies, causing hypoxia and threatening fish and other aquatic animals. These problems can arise both locally and regionally; for example, one of the principal causes for the increasing size of the Gulf of Mexico hypoxic zone is believed to be the increasing supply of nitrogen delivered to the Gulf from the Mississippi River Basin.

  5. @Mahlburg – Farmers are stewards of the land and with the cost of fertilizer constantly rising they aren't looking to throw money away with 'nutrient over-enrichment'. VRA is a great example of putting fertilizer where it is needed for the plant. Increasing yield and/or quality is the goal. It is the common household throwing tons of fertilizer to make their lawn green that provides more non-point source pollution than a farmer making a living.

  6. @Mahlburg – Farmers are stewards of the land and with the cost of fertilizer constantly rising they aren't looking to throw money away with 'nutrient over-enrichment'. VRA is a great example of putting fertilizer where it is needed for the plant. Increasing yield and/or quality is the goal. It is the common household throwing tons of fertilizer to make their lawn green that provides more non-point source pollution than a farmer making a living.

  7. VRA is a great technology, that is used profitably by thousands of growers annually through various on farm practices. Based on the cyclic nature of both weather and crop prices, many growers have a more difficult time understanding immediate payback on the technology, than the more adopted guidance and steering technologies. If you dig a bit deeper, there are many growers who have been practicing forms of VR for years, if not more than a decade with strong profitable results, albeit profitability varies from farm to farm based on many aspects of farm operations.

  8. VRA is a great technology, that is used profitably by thousands of growers annually through various on farm practices. Based on the cyclic nature of both weather and crop prices, many growers have a more difficult time understanding immediate payback on the technology, than the more adopted guidance and steering technologies. If you dig a bit deeper, there are many growers who have been practicing forms of VR for years, if not more than a decade with strong profitable results, albeit profitability varies from farm to farm based on many aspects of farm operations.

Guidance Stories
GuidanceTopcon Debuts SI-21 Lightbar for X-Family of Displays
February 28, 2017
Topcon Agriculture announces the release of the SI-21 Lightbar, designed as a cost-effective, user-friendly product to complement manual guidance, providing Read More
GuidanceTopcon Launching New X35 In-Cab Display Console
February 27, 2017
Topcon Agriculture introduces the new X35 — the next generation in the X-Family of touchscreen displays with advanced functionality. Designed Read More
Case IH - AFS AccuStar and UAV Offering - Magnum MX210 AccuStar Receiver
DronesCase IH Adds New GPS Solution, UAV Package To AFS Offerings
February 21, 2017
Driven by the growing demand for efficient data management, the latest Advanced Farming Systems (AFS) solutions from Case IH help Read More
GuidanceCase IH Launches AccuTurn Automated Headland-Turning Tech
February 15, 2017
New AccuTurn automated headland-turning technology from Case IH takes the guesswork out of turning on headlands, which gives you improved Read More
Trending Articles
Downed Drone
DronesOpinion: The Agricultural Drone War Is Over, And They Lost
March 15, 2017
If you are late to the aerial imagery party and think that agricultural drones are the vehicle that are the Read More
Nebraska Farmer
Business ManagementA Right To Repair: Why Nebraska Farmers Are Taking On John Deere And Apple
March 10, 2017
There are corn and soy fields as far as the eye can see around Kyle Schwarting’s home in Ceresco, NE, Read More
Australia crop
Ag Tech GlobalMaking Precision Agriculture Work In Australia
March 6, 2017
Editor’s note: Reinder Prins is Market Development Manager for Cotton Growers Service in Wee Waa, NSW, Australia, where he is Read More
ScoutPro | ScoutPro
Decision Support Software17 Field Scouting Apps For Precision Agriculture
February 6, 2017
There are dozens of easy-to-use mobile apps that are ideal for every day field scouting tasks. From record keeping and Read More
John Deere Dealership
Business ManagementAg Retailer, Equipment Dealer Improve Service By Working Together
January 27, 2017
Some believe that in many aspects of life, timing is everything. Among those believers, please count Randy Bartholomew, Integrated Solutions Read More
Innovation SeriesPrecision To Lead Agriculture In 2017?
January 25, 2017
Another new year is upon us! And I’m certain I speak for many in the agricultural world when I say Read More
Latest News
Farmer with iPad
Data ManagementRegaining Control Of Field Data
March 23, 2017
When it comes to creating and building value with farmer-customers, service providers today have new allies to support their efforts. Read More
Y-Drop 360 Yield
Tools & Smart EquipmentSplit Nitrogen Application: Where The 4Rs Get Real
March 23, 2017
When Illinois Grower Jeremy Wilson hit the farm conference circuit these past two years, one of his talks was always Read More
Hort TechSciFi in Ag: Robots Could Take Multi-Hybrid Planting Ne…
March 23, 2017
There is always the fear that robots will someday, maybe soon, take over the world. After all, Google has made Read More
Erich Eller ForeFront Ag Solutions with Ag Eagle-drone
Business ManagementForeFront Ag Solutions: Going Beyond The Averages
March 22, 2017
He’s flying essentially solo these days with business support from his wife Jennifer, but Erich Eller has big dreams for Read More
Ag Tech GlobalFarmobile Continues Connecting the Dots, adds Buyer to …
March 21, 2017
Farmobile announced today that Guy Carpenter, a global risk and reinsurance specialist, will purchase enhanced data sets to help optimize Read More
Valley Irrigation 8000 series corn
Hort TechValley Irrigation Now Exclusive OEM Provider of Trimble…
March 21, 2017
Valley Irrigation and Trimble announced that Valley Irrigation will become the exclusive OEM distributor of Trimble’s Irrigate-IQ precision irrigation solution, according Read More
Farmer Brad Hagen inspects cover crops
Business ManagementTop 5 Features Of A Good Sustainability Program
March 20, 2017
In a recent study, 60% of Iowa farmers agreed that their fertilizer dealers should do more to help them address Read More
Soil sampling Brazil
Ag Tech GlobalAn Overview Of Precision Ag In Brazil
March 17, 2017
Brazil is a huge player in international agriculture and precision farming is helping to increase productivity. With diverse crop production, Read More
Web Soil Survey soils map
Imagery/SensingCan The Web Soil Survey Help To Uncover Answers To Prec…
March 16, 2017
A farming magazine recently published an article of an interview of two experts discussing how understanding the topography of a Read More
Downed Drone
DronesOpinion: The Agricultural Drone War Is Over, And They L…
March 15, 2017
If you are late to the aerial imagery party and think that agricultural drones are the vehicle that are the Read More
Ag Retailer and Growers with tablet WinField United
Data ManagementEliminating Human Error In Precision Ag Data Documentat…
March 15, 2017
As precision ag consultants, we spend a lot of time working with clients to implement best management practices to acquire Read More
Curve Compensation ExactEmerge
ProfessionalsHow To Avoid Yield Loss Using Curve Compensation
March 15, 2017
Planting is often considered the most important step in a farming operation. For this reason, there have been many advancements Read More
IMPAC video
Hort TechHow Precision Agriculture Is Helping Farmers Win Over C…
March 14, 2017
“Your Food, Your Farmer” is a simple mantra, but one that resonates loudly with many of today’s consumers, writes Paul Read More
Brazil soil corn crop
Ag Tech GlobalA Precision Agriculture Project Starts With A Solid Fou…
March 13, 2017
I am a big fan of technologies in agriculture. I have become so impressed with the evolution of products and services Read More
Nebraska Farmer
Business ManagementA Right To Repair: Why Nebraska Farmers Are Taking On J…
March 10, 2017
There are corn and soy fields as far as the eye can see around Kyle Schwarting’s home in Ceresco, NE, Read More
Ag Tech GlobalCalifornia Ag Tech Outfit Releasing Internet-of-Crops P…
March 10, 2017
Centaur Analytics, a leading AgTech company that provides real-time, crops monitoring and protection solutions, today announced it has opened advanced registration for its Read More
Ag Retailer and Grower WinField United
ProfessionalsTop 5 Reasons Why Ag Retailers Need To Lead The Way In …
March 8, 2017
Smack dab in the middle of Iowa, you will find Casey’s General Store headquarters. For those of you who have Read More
Corn close up
Decision Support SoftwareUX in Ag: What are we Trying to do?
March 8, 2017
As designers, we’ve always considered ourselves outsiders—the unbiased third party in the agriculture world, writes co-authors Kayla Byington and Nick Read More