Risk In Agricultural Decisions

The concept of risk, especially in the context of a decision, is difficult to assess for a number of reasons. First, risk is more based on perception than facts. Paul Slovic, a psychologist who has done landmark studies over the past three decades, identified key characteristics that helped define human perception of risk. He found that people did not tolerate risks that were perceived as lacking control, associated with dread, had a catastrophic potential, had fatal consequences, and would result in an inequitable distribution of risks and benefits.

The classic example of a perceived risk that is uncontrollable and potentially catastrophic is a nuclear power plant. While modern plants have numerous safeguards to prevent a meltdown, they are perceived as highly dangerous by many individuals because they lack personal control over them. Ironically, some of the same people who perceive nuclear power plants as high risk do not use seatbelts while driving a car or wear a helmet when riding a motorcycle. Even though it is well-documented that seatbelts and helmets prevent serious head injuries in an accident, these people believe they are in control of their vehicles and bikes at all times.

Second, risk can be in the form of an extremely rare event. Nassim Taleb, in his book “The Black Swan,” defines a “black swan” as an event that is unexpected, extremely impactful, and difficult to predict. Black swans are so rare that people are unprepared for their occurrence. In some sense, the risk of a black swan is incalculable as it is catastrophic.

An example of a black swan is the Big Thompson Flood which occurred in Colorado in 1976. This flood was considered a one-in-1,000-year event and therefore beyond the living memory of many generations. Its occurrence was unexpected, impactful, and unpredictable by forecasting techniques at that time.

Third, the concept of risk is shaped by our educational and cultural backgrounds. People fear what they do not understand and people reject positions and/or practices that are not politically or socially acceptable. Education exposes individuals to new ways of thinking and to facts beyond those collected through experience. New technologies and novel solutions can challenge a position or practice.

Lastly, risk can be difficult to assess due to too little or too much data or information. In most cases, an individual may understand the underlying logic for processes affecting a decision but lack the data to reasonably predict an outcome. In a few cases, an individual may be overwhelmed by too much data and suspend any logical thinking when making a decision. In these cases, a person will focus on one or two variables to assess the behavior of a complex system.

Remembering The Odds

Risk by definition is associated with loss and everyone tries to avoid it. However, in order to take advantage of new technologies, products, and/or services, we accept certain calculated risks since they are part of our lifestyle and jobs. For example, it is almost certainty that over a lifetime everyone will experience some type of non-fatal automobile accident.

The same is true for food poisoning, a burn, electric shock, or injury. This social acceptance of risk is well-illustrated by the example of electricity. Michio Kaku, a popular physicist and futurist, noted that after the invention of electricity, many people resisted the building of an electrical infrastructure due to the fear of electrocution. And they were right. The risk of electrocution was real and it still exists today. In fact, according to the American Burn Association, there are on average 400 deaths and 4,400 injuries due to electrical hazards. We, as a society, accept this risk because the benefits of an electrical infrastructure far outweigh the likelihood of an individual experiencing death from electrocution.

While one can never rule out a “black swan” occurring in agriculture, most of our concerns about risk have to do with data and information, education, and cultural practices because the decisions we make are under our control. With that attention, there are a few steps we can take to minimize risk in our production decisions.

A Five-Step Approach

First, keep good records. In agriculture, as in other environmental systems, history repeats itself. There are predictable patterns in weather, crops, and pests.

Second, expect the unexpected. While a growing season may appear to be similar to a previous one, there will always be subtle differences. A selected hybrid may be less sensitive to environmental stresses but more susceptible to a new pest.

Third, whenever possible, have more than one solution to a problem. For example, weather conditions may result in a narrow planting window and therefore additional equipment may be required to complete seeding by a desired date. Or a worker may become sick at critical time requiring the temporary hiring of additional personnel.

Fourth, understand the technology supporting a decision. Whether its software or equipment, be sure everything works and has been calibrated to your specific field setting and operation.

Lastly, seek advice and learn from others. We are living in an information age. Help is just a key stroke or call away. While you may be facing a new event, such as a herbicide-resistant weed, you can be sure someone else in another location has experienced the same event in a previous year.

Leave a Reply

Decision Support Software Stories
Trimble Connected Farm Dashboard ipad and desktop
Decision Support SoftwareWhat’s The Deal With Dashboards? — A Seinfeldian Look At Farm Management Information Systems
March 1, 2017
First off, if you read that title in the voice of Jerry Seinfeld, I have your attention, and you also Read More
Australian Harvest
Decision Support SoftwareGarden City Co-op Added as MZB Regional Mapping Center; Two Kansas Coops Sign On with MZB
February 17, 2017
Garden City Co-op (GCC), through a retailer agreement, has been using MZB Technologies as their precision ag platform for a Read More
Connected Farm Scout Trimble Agriculture - featured image
Decision Support Software17 Field Scouting Apps For Precision Agriculture
February 6, 2017
There are dozens of easy-to-use mobile apps that are ideal for every day field scouting tasks. From record keeping and Read More
IBM The Weather Company
Decision Support SoftwareCustomized Weather Forecasts, Image Recognition Highlight IBM’s Foray Into Agriculture
January 27, 2017
Many in business were puzzled when IBM announced plans to purchase The Weather Company in 2016. Then last summer IBM Read More
Trending Articles
Connected Farm Scout Trimble Agriculture - featured image
Decision Support Software17 Field Scouting Apps For Precision Agriculture
February 6, 2017
There are dozens of easy-to-use mobile apps that are ideal for every day field scouting tasks. From record keeping and Read More
John Deere Dealership
Business ManagementAg Retailer, Equipment Dealer Improve Service By Working Together
January 27, 2017
Some believe that in many aspects of life, timing is everything. Among those believers, please count Randy Bartholomew, Integrated Solutions Read More
Innovation SeriesPrecision To Lead Agriculture In 2017?
January 25, 2017
Another new year is upon us! And I’m certain I speak for many in the agricultural world when I say Read More
Terry Griffin
Business ManagementUsing High Tech To Make Farm Decisions
January 17, 2017
Raj Khosla, professor of precision agriculture at Colorado State University, challenged farmers to think about how far the technology of Read More
PrecisionAg.com featured image
ProfessionalsWelcome to the Newly Enhanced PrecisionAg.com
December 29, 2016
Talk a quick look around our website and we hope you’ll notice it’s significantly different as we head into 2017 Read More
Ryan Raguse and Matthew Grassi
ProfessionalsIndustry Executives Talk New PrecisionAg Professional Brand
December 19, 2016
EFC Systems President and CEO Ernie Chappell Myriad Mobile Cofounder and Chairman Ryan Raguse Read More
Latest News
linkedin-groups
Professionals5 Compelling Reasons To Join The PrecisionAg Profession…
March 1, 2017
Many ag professionals are actively using sites such as Twitter and Facebook to promote their businesses. But perhaps no other Read More
Trimble Connected Farm Dashboard ipad and desktop
Decision Support SoftwareWhat’s The Deal With Dashboards? — A Seinfeldian Look A…
March 1, 2017
First off, if you read that title in the voice of Jerry Seinfeld, I have your attention, and you also Read More
GuidanceTopcon Debuts SI-21 Lightbar for X-Family of Displays
February 28, 2017
Topcon Agriculture announces the release of the SI-21 Lightbar, designed as a cost-effective, user-friendly product to complement manual guidance, providing Read More
Imagery/SensingAgrible Launches Pocket Drone Control App for Crop Copt…
February 28, 2017
Agrible has a new tool to help the farming community by giving users the power of aerial insights. Pocket Drone Read More
GuidanceTopcon Launching New X35 In-Cab Display Console
February 27, 2017
Topcon Agriculture introduces the new X35 — the next generation in the X-Family of touchscreen displays with advanced functionality. Designed Read More
Brazilian Agriculture
Ag Tech GlobalInside The Life Of A Precision Ag Consultant In Brazil
February 27, 2017
Editor’s note: Maurício Nicocelli Netto is a Precision Ag Consultant in Brazil. While he has witnessed a lot of growth in Read More
Professor Simon Blackmore
Ag Tech GlobalUK Professor: Name Change Needed For ‘Precision A…
February 24, 2017
‘Accurate farming’ would be more apt than ‘precision agriculture’ to describe this agricultural practice, says professor Simon Blackmore of Harper Read More
EventsInnovation Series 2017 Quick Thoughts: Gaining Ground
February 23, 2017
If you’ve been following past coverage of our PrecisionAg® Media Innovation Series events, this column is going to sound a Read More
UNL Researchers
ProfessionalsPrecision Agriculture Makes Farming More Sustainable, P…
February 23, 2017
Farmers have numerous sources of technology and data available to use in their operations, but many producers struggle with what Read More
Ag Tech GlobalSciFi in Ag: What do North Dakota, Peru, and Mars Have …
February 23, 2017
In early 2016, I was lucky enough to hike the Salkantay Mountain range in Peru. It’s about a 50 mile Read More
Sentera drone
DronesPrecision Ag Professionals Will Find Advice, Applicatio…
February 22, 2017
The upcoming ASCEND Conference & Expo will deliver practical information about using drones to improve processes in precision agriculture. ASCEND Read More
Case IH - AFS AccuStar and UAV Offering - Magnum MX210 AccuStar Receiver
DronesCase IH Adds New GPS Solution, UAV Package To AFS Offer…
February 21, 2017
Driven by the growing demand for efficient data management, the latest Advanced Farming Systems (AFS) solutions from Case IH help Read More
Mobile Phone in field
Systems ManagementBayer Enters Farm Recommendations Arena With Yara Colla…
February 20, 2017
Crop protection and ag biotech giant Bayer and fertilizer producer Yara International ASA have entered into a software collaboration and Read More
Hort TechGrowingProduce.com: Smart Vineyards Set to Revolutioniz…
February 17, 2017
Phil Asmundson is by no means a veteran viticulturist, but a half-dozen years ago, after watching his wife and business Read More
Soil testing
Data ManagementOpinion: Soil Testing Needs Sensors To Get More Accurat…
February 17, 2017
We are entering a very exciting time in agriculture. With so many great software platforms and data collection tools we Read More
Australian Harvest
Decision Support SoftwareGarden City Co-op Added as MZB Regional Mapping Center;…
February 17, 2017
Garden City Co-op (GCC), through a retailer agreement, has been using MZB Technologies as their precision ag platform for a Read More
DronesLand O’Lakes Drone Challenge Crowdsourcing Compet…
February 17, 2017
Land O’Lakes, Inc. is calling on innovators from the tech industry to enter the Land O’Lakes Prize: Drone Challenge, a Read More
DronesDrone Startup Hits VC Jackpot: Skyward Acquired by Veri…
February 16, 2017
Building on its strategy to drive innovation and adoption for IoT services in high-growth markets, Verizon today announced that it Read More