Opinion: The Yearly Death of Ag Data

So that headline sounds somewhat dark and ominous, doesn’t it? The thing about it is that it’s actually been happening for some time now. When you look at all the data that has been somewhat carelessly created by the various machines and controllers out there, it made me think that most of it is wasted and never used for anything. Heck, some are even trying to say it’s worth something, and while that’s great, it doesn’t really solve the issue. Why is this happening and what can be done to stop it or make the data more practical to be utilized?

[Related: Opinion: ROI or Die in Precision Agriculture]

First off, let’s look back to gain some perspective. Since the inception of monitors in the cab in the mid-90s there has been data being produced. This was done for very practical reasons, but because using any technology in the ag industry is by nature — for the lack of better term —  “slow paced,” most people never really got used to it. Everyone was enamored with the yield number or autosteer and not having to drive, but actually doing something with the data was still generally painful.

dataSure, there are all the different new technologies that make data management easier through wireless transfer, telematics, cloud computing or other methods. But even if the data is getting transferred somewhere, are people actually using that data? Data can be used for many things, from monitoring what the planter did, where and what was sprayed or fertilized, and how much was harvested and where, to using it for crop insurance and sustainability reporting, creating prescriptions, unfortunate litigations and lawful needs, or just basic tracking of what was done for comfort. While I’m not sure what the exact adoption rate for data usage is, but from what I’ve seen it’s still pretty low.

My main point is there needs to be a greater effort in using this data by people in general because there is plenty of opportunity to do so. Also, the groups that claim they can do all these great things with data need to step up their game with better education of what can be done and what the real benefit is, not just that it can be created and transferred. There needs to be more incentives to data usage, not just saying “hey, you could do this or that,” but more of “if you use it, you get this.”

Of course, the biggest problem really when you get down to it is data privacy. Many people I have spoken with have said growers often say “I don’t want anyone to have my data.” I know this conversation has been ongoing for some time now, but the ag industry isn’t doing a good enough job of tackling the data privacy issue and most of the money coming into ag tech doesn’t care about what the farmer really wants.

So, when we really start digging down in the dirt (pun intended) to why data isn’t used more in the ag industry and how it’s likely headed into another season of its untimely death, I hope this article will help open up the conversation and get things moving to change this issue. With the ag economy being what it is, growers need all they can to make sure they can make it through these troubled waters, and so do the companies that use and create the data as well. Maybe just maybe using some of this data can provide a better chance of that compared to the past. At the end of the day, we really just need to start using the tools in the tool box instead of staring at the tool chest. There is still time this season, so let’s just stop talking about the benefits of data and actually do something with it.

Leave a Reply

8 comments on “Opinion: The Yearly Death of Ag Data

  1. Well said. I would simply reply that “the groups that claim they can do all these great things with data” (citation from above text) have not figured out which data is important because within field situations differ from one place to another. You need to find out which data to collect (experienced required, NDVI misused), determine which data can explain yield/quality variations and establish how to correct the situation. This is somehow like doing research in the fields because there is no “one size fits all” solution. Solutions are not in the books/publications yet and using simple solutions does not work (ie. NDVI based variable rate nitrogen management). You need to adapt your precision agriculture project to each situation and integrate several data (not always the same ones) before proposing agronomic solutions.
    Companies want a simple “one size fits all” solution for marketing and ease of application reasons but it just does not work this way in the environment. All they obtain is reluctance from farmers to adopt PA.
    More efficient brain use is required but it seems to me noone has truly understood it. Brains are presently used for marketing but real data (yearly yield comparisons) brings it back to the drawing board.
    This situation dates several years back and the main problem that can be pointed is a misunderstanding of what specific data means agronomically. For example, the main multispêctral data (NDVI) is used as “plant health”-related data which it is not at all but someone has called it this way and because it was marketable, it has been adopted this way. NDVI is used as an instantaneous data whereas it is mainly a cumulative data. Using data the wrong way leads to wrong conclusions and inefficient solutions.
    There are other examples but this message is already too long. Contact me in case you (reader) want efficient agronomic solutions. I do not bite, all I want is to develop efficient projects.

  2. Very interesting piece. I work with Stratus Ag Research, and I am the project manager for a new syndicated market research study that we just completed this Spring on Field Data Management in North America. The objective of the study was to better understand farmer’s data management practices, the utilization of software and track their experiences with the current software brands in the market today.
    We talked with 496 farmers in the Midwest (those who planted >1000 acres in 2016) and I can tell you that 84% indicated they have equipment that is capturing precision data (data tied to GIS), so as you say there is a lot of data being produced. 42% of farmers claim to be using software to further analyze this data. It is our intention to repeat the study again in 2017 and dig a little deeper into the specifics of those analytics. Feel free to contact me if you would like further information on our study.

  3. Data – Information – Knowledge… these are not synonymous!

    Data, are just numbers.

    Information is when these data in context as to where, what sensor, when measurements….How and why the data came to be…..now that is knowledge.

    Knowledge is what we make decisions with.

  4. Having .YLD files with GPS georeference going back to harvest 1996, I know the concerns and frustrations many farmers feel. I also know that sharing/storing digital agriculture data is more like handing over negatives of photos than sharing or loaning out one’s tools or automobile. The latter are more easily inventoried once returned. Getting back one’s original photo negative doesn’t mean copies don’t exist for the use of others.

    This is intellectual property that has value for time to come. Yes, the original owner might be missing out on opportunities from the data, but it’s one thing to miss the opportunity it’s another to provide the ammunition for a competitor down the road to take over your operation using the data you provide.

    It is unclear whether ethics have evolved with the ability to capture data (who do you trust?). If you look at society as a whole, one would suggest ethical behavior is less commonplace. Thus, many would err on the side of caution….. “am I getting in bed with the wrong players?”

    So, we have technological capabilities that are growing incredibly fast. We have sensors capable of capturing tremendous amounts of information. We have data processing, modeling twisting this data every which way. Yet, a majority of the acres around the world are at the whims of Mother Nature who can drive numerous critical elements of “the plan” to the extreme edges of the curve in a matter of hours or weeks. The question becomes, “how much precision is precise enough?” That is, looking through which end of the funnel gives the farmer the information needed to survive those whims of nature?

    A lot of people and organizations think they have an answer to that question for a price yet it is unclear whether they really know what they don’t know either. I would guess the that the common cold will be cured before this fundamental issue with open field agriculture is solved.

  5. Seems like peer-to-peer experience-sharing opportunities for farmers to discuss and share real world data/knowledge use is one way companies can “…to step up their game with better education of what can be done and what the real benefit is, not just that it can be created and transferred”.

Data Management Stories
Texas-and-Oklahoma-Panhandles-Google-Earth
Data ManagementAgriculture Impacts Weather: The Case for Connected Ecosystems
February 15, 2018
It’s fascinating to see how modern technology has helped us increase our agricultural productivity in areas not otherwise suited for Read More
Norris planter
Data ManagementBig Data is a Chicken-or-Egg Scenario on the Farm
February 1, 2018
According to McKinsey, the agricultural sector is the least digitized industry in the U.S., writes Tony Baer on ZDNet.com. Yet, Read More
Business Management2018 Retail Precision Ag Programs: At-A-Glance
February 1, 2018
Deep in the midst off December downtime, we reached out to three retailers well-versed in running a grower-facing precision ag Read More
Data ManagementClimate Corp. Announces CNH Data Sharing Partnership
February 1, 2018
CNH Industrial and The Climate Corporation announced today a new partnership that will extend and develop a portfolio of data Read More
Trending Articles
India-Farm-Irrigation
AsiaCloud-based Irrigation Could Double India’s Crop Yield and Halve Water Use
February 12, 2018
A cloud-based, micro-irrigation system tested on a farm in India has cut water use by up to 80%  and doubled Read More
Tools & Smart EquipmentAutonomous Tractors Could Work in Wetter Conditions than Traditional Tractors
February 8, 2018
March 20th is the first day of spring, making spring much closer than even I expected. On the farm I Read More
AmericasPrecision Farming Companies to Watch in 2018 (OPINION)
January 17, 2018
My friends, as many of you told me repeatedly throughout the last 12 months, 2017 was an interesting year in Read More
John-Deere-Cab-GPS
Data ManagementPrecision Ag Hardware and Software: A Little Off-Season Maintenance Goes A Long Way
January 11, 2018
All service technicians have heard this line. Most often when spring makes its anticipated return to our lives. It is Read More
Anez-Consulting-Paul-Anez-and-Michael-Dunn
Service ProvidersAnez Consulting: Focus On Fertility
January 9, 2018
Central Minnesota features variability aplenty when it comes to soil characteristics and topography, from flat, black expanses rich in organic Read More
Agrishow2017
Americas5 Best Ag Tech Shows in Brazil
January 8, 2018
Brazil continues to demonstrate its potential in agriculture. Several international companies are investing in our country because we have a Read More
Latest News
Harvested-Corn-Field-Clouds
Industry NewsUnderstory Patents Solid State Weather Sensor
February 16, 2018
Understory today announced that it received a patent for its mechanical strain-based weather sensor, a key component in its weather Read More
Retailer Grower
Business ManagementAgriculture and Technology: Industry Progress Lies in C…
February 16, 2018
Water is essential for agriculture. While this may seem obvious, nowhere is it more apparent than the Sonoran Desert of Read More
Agtegra_SDSU
Industry NewsAgtegra Cooperative Pledges $500,000 to SDSU Precision …
February 15, 2018
Agtegra Cooperative, Aberdeen, SD, today in Pierre announced a $500,000 donation to South Dakota State University for the Precision Agriculture Read More
Ag Retailer and Grower WinField United
Business ManagementThe Importance of Teamwork for Successful Precision Ag …
February 15, 2018
Interdependency is defined as the quality or condition of being mutually reliant on each other. I’m not a huge sports Read More
Texas-and-Oklahoma-Panhandles-Google-Earth
Data ManagementAgriculture Impacts Weather: The Case for Connected Eco…
February 15, 2018
It’s fascinating to see how modern technology has helped us increase our agricultural productivity in areas not otherwise suited for Read More
Adapt-N VRT
Decision Support SoftwareDTN Partners with Adapt-N to Provide Weather and Nitrog…
February 14, 2018
DTN has announced a partnership today at the National Farm Machinery Show with Agronomic Technology Corp (ATC), a Yara International Read More
Corn close up
Imagery/SensingSyngenta Acquires Satellite Imagery Provider FarmShots
February 14, 2018
Syngenta has acquired FarmShots, Inc., a North Carolina-based innovator of high-resolution satellite imagery that detects plant health by analyzing absorbed Read More
Pexels-Agriculture_Fields_Tractor_Precision_AG
Tools & Smart EquipmentMachine Learning: The Secret Sauce of Precision Agricul…
February 13, 2018
With the development of agricultural technologies, crop and plant diseases have been advancing as well, causing degradation of both quality Read More
Farmers Edge Truck
Africa/Middle EastFarmers Edge Aligns with PartnerRE to Streamline Crop I…
February 13, 2018
Today Winnipeg-based FMIS giant Farmers Edge announced a partnership around crop insurance with Zurich-based PartnerRE. Although a bit short on Read More
Robotics Specialty Crops
AmericasHortau, Agrian Announce Strategic Partnership
February 12, 2018
Hortau today announced a strategic partnership with Agrian Inc. to deliver an expansive precision irrigation service for commercial agriculture. “With Read More
India-Farm-Irrigation
AsiaCloud-based Irrigation Could Double India’s Crop Yield …
February 12, 2018
A cloud-based, micro-irrigation system tested on a farm in India has cut water use by up to 80%  and doubled Read More
Forbes Mixing Bowl NYC
EventsInnovative Forum Geared to Let Food, Farming, and Tech …
February 9, 2018
Industry innovators in agriculture, food, and information technology are set to mix it up again at this year’s Forbes Mixing Read More
Tools & Smart EquipmentAutonomous Tractors Could Work in Wetter Conditions tha…
February 8, 2018
March 20th is the first day of spring, making spring much closer than even I expected. On the farm I Read More
corn weather
Industry NewsSciFi in Ag: Stanford Cooling Project Could Drive Energ…
February 7, 2018
(Article Notes: This monthly column takes some crazy sounding ideas and applies them to the field of Ag Tech. The Read More
Industry NewsAgGateway Debuts ADAPT ISO Plugin Version 2.0
February 6, 2018
AgGateway’s ADAPT Framework, which is designed to make it easy for various hardware and software systems that growers use in Read More
Roger-DuMond-and-Brandon-Butz-Kova-Fertilizer
Systems ManagementThere’s No Easy Button For Value in Variable-Rate Nutri…
February 6, 2018
Roger Dumond has weathered the ups and downs of precision agriculture programs as much as anybody who’s been riding that Read More
Farmer-Soybean-field
Business ManagementFeel Something is Missing in Precision Agriculture? Ans…
February 5, 2018
I’ve seen a lot of ideas and met a lot of people in the agtech world. There have been great Read More
HomeSST Software to be Acquired by Proagrica
February 5, 2018
UPDATED 2.5.18, 2:10 PM Proagrica has signed an agreement to acquire 100% of SST Software, including Raven’s ownership stake. Based Read More