Nailing Down The Value Of Data

Norris planter
Many stakeholders believe grower data can be a goldmine of information, but there’s still a host of factors limiting the payoff.

There’s been quite a dust-up in the past few years about who owns a grower’s data and what agriculture technology providers (ATPs) can do with it. It reached the point where the American Farm Bureau stepped in, leading efforts to draw up guidelines for use of producers’ information in 2014. But just what’s so great about data that everyone wants it?

PrecisionAg® magazine reached out to a number of consultants and growers to see how they measure the value of data. They agreed there are monetary benefits in higher yields and saved input costs. Then too, more precise practices and use of products makes sense for the environment.

Our contacts also agreed that yield data was the Holy Grail, the most important information collected. Some called it a score card, a report card of everything that went before in the season. And as such, how it’s interpreted impacts future agronomic decisions — from variable-rate seeding recommendations to nutrient tracking to simply picking the best variety, says Steve Cubbage, President, Prime Meridian, Nevada, MO.

Tim Norris, Ag InfoTech
Tim Norris, Ag InfoTech

Planting data came right behind yield information in value. As Tim Norris, CEO of Ag Info Tech LLC, Mount Vernon, OH, puts it: “Planting is the most important job we can do as a grain farmer. If we don’t find issues and correct them during planting, we have limited our yield potential right from the start.”

In fact, Norris says producers can do much better collecting data at planting. Thanks to displays with Internet connections, I envision a day when growers can automatically collect and record current weather conditions. In addition, sensors on the planter could automatically collect soil temperature and moisture.

Yield data gets more valuable when it’s supplemented with planter ride, downforce, seeding accuracy, and crop input application information, says Cubbage. “We’re not getting the whole picture,” he worries. “That’s a shame because we’re missing out on what could be some easy answers to manage crops.”

But isn’t there “low value” data in an operation? Definitely not, agreed our contacts, provided it’s quality data.

In fact, a few growers are shooting to record everything that happens in a field. Most recently, Grower Steve Pitstick, Maple Park, IL, began documenting the footprints of machine operations in his fields — movement of tillage units, grain carts, etc. The idea is to look at all the impacts of compaction on yield, to correlate it to imagery or to whatever measure he can.

Norris has clients that have been collecting information on both tillage and grain cart trips and sees traffic patterns show up in row-by-row downforce maps. Having these layers of information can help identify what caused the patterns and possible field problems.

Pitstick admits he might not find value in all data collected today, but in the future event that he can, he says that with such stored information, he’ll be ahead of his peers.

Nathan Wentworth, Wentworth Farms
Nathan Wentworth, Wentworth Farms

Indeed, Nathan Wentworth, Wentworth Farms, Warrensburg, IL, says that looking back, he wishes he had collected certain data sooner. He won’t label anything as low value if he can gather it easily, economically and accurately. He envisions a time when he’ll be able to analyze it and potentially make actionable decisions with it.

Wentworth is also focused on improving how he collects data. “We have made a significant investment into the Precision Planting and FieldView platforms to improve the simplicity and accuracy of our planting and yield data,” he says. “We’ve been impressed with FieldView and are very excited to gather all of our field data through this platform in the not too distant future.”

Quality The Biggest Limitation

While data may be valuable, growers can face real struggles collecting it right. A number of our experts believe the biggest limitation of data today is its quality.

Jeremy Wilson, Technology Specialist for Crop IMS, Effingham, IL, seriously questions the quality of the data collected by the average grower. “We’re creating mountains, and we’ve got more big data solutions that are going to take these mountains and bring us solutions and answers. But if it’s junk, what do we have to gain?” he says. “I think too many big data solutions are not giving any credit to the quality of data they may be getting, and I don’t know how to address it.”

Poor education by the industry ranked high as a reason for bad data. “Growers are promised things that their monitors and systems can produce and all the things they can do with data. But no one teaches them what it takes to produce good data that can actually be used in making decisions,” says Ben Flansburg, BCA Ag Technologies, Medina, NY. Too many times, the customers’ mounds of data he sees aren’t useable, the problems caused because something wasn’t calibrated or parameters were not set correctly.

There haven’t been incentives to do a good job calibrating because growers just don’t know what they’ll do with the data produced anyway, says Pitstick. “Kind of like the chicken and the egg,” he notes. But as systems become easier to calibrate, quality will get better.

Prime Meridian’s Cubbage has found information submitted to firms for analysis is generally unorganized, uncalibrated, and typically missing large chunks of valuable data.  “This is the reality on the ground, and growers and agri-professionals are, in my opinion, not addressing this serious issue,” he says. “Properly collecting a foundational data set such as where different varieties are planted, and what population they are planted at, then collecting calibrated yield data at the end is not the norm.” He adds that the problems are seriously holding back the industry, including the potential promised by Big Data.

Other production information pieces — such as rainfall, planting locations and planting dates — needed for decision-making are missing as well. If yield data is the report card, then all that’s gone before is the lesson plan, says Pitstick. But most growers don’t carefully record the lesson plan. “Guys keep track of stuff on a clipboard on a tractor or a calendar in the shop,” he says. “But that doesn’t do much good because it’s not spatial, it’s not anything we can look at on a digitized map. It’s very hard to do analysis on those parts of the lesson plan that aren’t digitized.”

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Nailing Down The Value Of Data

  1. Interesting article and highlights many of the issues. Chicken and egg around getting farmers to collect high quality data. Is an interesting one, but I don’t think many people really understand big data, and we certainly don’t have the analytics in place. We need to understand the difference between data and information, get our heads around customers desire for visualisation etc. timeframe might not be right for investors looking to make a quick buck or a big buck as work required to bring about change is totally underestimated. Change is going to be constant and rapid which will also have an effect on the potential profitability of such ventures. I like the comment about white knights, illustrates the problem about lack of understanding.

Data Management Stories
Data ManagementNew Partnerhship Between AgIntegrated, CDMS, SeediQ Will Create Single Source Reference Data API
January 18, 2017
AgIntegrated, Inc. (AGI), CDMS, Inc. and SeediQ announce a partnership to develop, promote, and sell a single-source crop input reference Read More
Data ManagementProspera Selected for Top 100 Artificial Intelligence Rankings
January 11, 2017
CB Insights today selected Prospera to the prestigious Artificial Intelligence 100 list (“AI 100”), a select group of emerging private Read More
Corn Field
Data ManagementWaypoint Analytical, Highland Precision Ag Announce Strategic Alliance
January 9, 2017
Waypoint Analytical (WP), based in Memphis, TN, and Highland Precision Ag (HPA), based in Mulberry, FL, are pleased to announce Read More
Wade Barnes Farmers Edge using FarmCommand
Data ManagementFarmers Edge Makes Precision Ag Simple
January 3, 2017
Jon Labine of Argyle, MN, is a regional sales representative for Farmers Edge Inc., one of the latest entries in Read More
Trending Articles featured image
ProfessionalsWelcome to the Newly Enhanced
December 29, 2016
Talk a quick look around our website and we hope you’ll notice it’s significantly different as we head into 2017 Read More
Ryan Raguse and Matthew Grassi
ProfessionalsIndustry Executives Talk New PrecisionAg Professional Brand
December 19, 2016
EFC Systems President and CEO Ernie Chappell Myriad Mobile Cofounder and Chairman Ryan Raguse Read More
PrecisionAg Professional logo
Industry NewsMeister Media Debuts PrecisionAg Professional
December 13, 2016
Agricultural technology is accelerating, and precision agriculture is gaining renewed interest across cropping systems. At the same time, growers are Read More
Sensors/IoTNew Farming Focused IoT Partnership Announced
December 13, 2016
Infiswift, an enterprise Internet of Things (IoT) platform developer, announces a partnership to develop IoT solutions with Acuitus Ag, an Read More
GVM E-Series cab
Ag Tech GlobalGlobalization And Precision Agriculture
December 7, 2016
Globalization has taken on a negative connotation in some circles in the U.S. in recent months. The lightning rod for Read More
Farmers Edge Truck
Data ManagementFarmers Edge, Trotter Fertilizer Form Partnership To Enhance VRT Programs
November 29, 2016
Farmers Edge, a global leader in precision agriculture and independent data management solutions, has partnered with Trotter Fertilizer, Nebraska’s foremost Read More
Latest News
Sonny Perdue
Business ManagementAg Tech CEOs Weigh In On Trump’s Pick For Ag Secr…
January 20, 2017
With President-Elect Donald Trump’s selection of Sonny Perdue as the new proposed Secretary of Agriculture, it brings a new set Read More
BASF Maglis Grower Tablet
EventsRetailers, Consultants Untangle Software Decision Proce…
January 19, 2017
Today, business and agronomy management software is the engine that facilitates a smooth running ag business. The next software decision Read More
Ag Weather Service
Decision Support SoftwareSciFi in Ag: Will Amazon’s Alexa Control the Fami…
January 19, 2017
*Article Notes: This monthly column takes some crazy sounding ideas and applies them to the field of Ag Tech. The Read More
Data ManagementNew Partnerhship Between AgIntegrated, CDMS, SeediQ Wil…
January 18, 2017
AgIntegrated, Inc. (AGI), CDMS, Inc. and SeediQ announce a partnership to develop, promote, and sell a single-source crop input reference Read More
Corn Field Sunset
Ag Tech GlobalAg Technology Among Focus Areas For Kohli Impact Invest…
January 18, 2017
Tej Kohli, a serial entrepreneur, global businessman and philanthropist, has announced he has earmarked an initial $25 million USD, through his Read More
Terry Griffin
Business ManagementUsing High Tech To Make Farm Decisions
January 17, 2017
Raj Khosla, professor of precision agriculture at Colorado State University, challenged farmers to think about how far the technology of Read More
Decisive Farming My Farm Manager mobile app
Ag Tech GlobalLeading Canadian Farming Co-op Brings In New Tech To Bo…
January 17, 2017
Co-op, one of the largest agricultural retailers in Western Canada, is partnering with farm management company Decisive Farming to provide Read More
Business ManagementCNH Names Danford Industry Relations Manager
January 17, 2017
Dan Danford has been named Industry Relations Manager, Precision Solutions and Telematics (PS&T), for CNH Industrial, parent company of agricultural Read More
Australian Harvest
Ag Tech GlobalAustralian Precision Agriculture Market, Forecast To 20…
January 13, 2017
Research and Markets has announced the addition of the “Australian Precision Agriculture Market, Forecast to 2020” report to their offering. Read More
Norris planter
Innovation SeriesCompelling Consultant Panel Kicks Off Next Month’s Prec…
January 12, 2017
Jeremy Wilson, Technology Specialist at CropIMS and renowned precision expert, leads a panel of top precision consultants to kick off Read More
Data ManagementProspera Selected for Top 100 Artificial Intelligence R…
January 11, 2017
CB Insights today selected Prospera to the prestigious Artificial Intelligence 100 list (“AI 100”), a select group of emerging private Read More
Business ManagementBREAKING: FAA Considering Less Restrictive Commercial D…
January 11, 2017
FAA is working toward allowing more freedom for drone operators, and at the same time is working with NASA on Read More
DronessenseFly, Agribotix Combine eBee SQ and FarmLens Offeri…
January 11, 2017
Agribotix has partnered with senseFly to offer a new combined solution for professional users. This technology solution combines the top Read More
Sentera software
DronesSentera Announces NDVI Livestream Capabilities for Doub…
January 10, 2017
Sentera today announced the upcoming release of LiveNDVI Video: livestreamed NDVI video via Sentera’s Double 4K sensor. This breakthrough technology Read More
Young Corn Field
Ag Tech GlobalEurocontrol To Commercialize Precision Agricultural Ini…
January 9, 2017
Eurocontrol Technics Group Inc., a Canadian public company specializing in the acquisition, development and commercialization of innovative test and measurement Read More
Corn Field
Data ManagementWaypoint Analytical, Highland Precision Ag Announce Str…
January 9, 2017
Waypoint Analytical (WP), based in Memphis, TN, and Highland Precision Ag (HPA), based in Mulberry, FL, are pleased to announce Read More
Western Canada Wheat field
EventsSixth Annual Precision Ag Summit Set for January 16-17 …
January 4, 2017
The 6th annual Precision Ag Summit will be held Jan. 16-17, at the North Dakota Farmers Union Conference Center in Read More
University of California Merced Professor Stefano Carpin
Hort TechRobots, People Working Together To Save Water, Enhance …
January 3, 2017
A nearly $1 million grant from the USDA is helping University of California researchers refine collaborative robotic technology that could Read More