Handicapping Data In Precision Agriculture

Predicting crop yield is analogous to predicting a winner in a horse race. In both cases, there are a lot of variables to consider and decisions are a mix of art and science. Serious bettors analyze data on past performances and then handicap horses for their chance of winning or placing in a race. Handicapping is very personal and there are as many approaches as there are handicappers. While decisions on which horse will win what race will vary among handicappers, they all start with the same source of information — a racing form.

A racing form provides a wide range of data on a horse’s past performance. It lists the tracks and length of races during the past few years, the jockeys riding the horse, track surface type and conditions, horse gender, age, and weight, quality of the competition, positions at the starting post, during a race, and at the finish line, and percentage of winning. There are also subtle statistics such as speed of last race, class rating, and best speed at distance. Modern racing forms include algorithms, such as “prime power,” which combine a number of handicapping variables into a single rating. The challenge to a bettor is to correctly handicap a set of variables according to their importance in determining a profitable outcome for a race. The chosen set of variables will vary from track to track and race to race. Successful handicappers stress the need for flexibility and creativity when choosing variables.

Handicapping Data

Like racing, growers need to handicap their data when growing a crop. And like racing, one can imagine a “farming form” for crop production. A farming form like a racing form would vary from grower to grower because each has a different history with fields, crop varieties and yield performances. While their prioritization may change from grower to grower and region to region, one can identify a common set of variables important for production decision-making. Just as important as the order of importance of variables is the availability of data for them.

If a field can be imagined as being analogous to a track, a farming form would likely list the soil texture and fertility as the first two variables for handicapping. Soil is the stage on which a crop performs and its texture and fertility determines the quality of that performance. Just as a race track can be turf, dirt, or synthetic (man-made materials), a soil can have a mixed texture of sand, silt, or clay and varying amounts of macro- and micronutrients. The depth and mixture of textures determines rooting depth, aeration, and water-holding capacity, while fertility impacts crop health.

The third variable on a farming form would probably be weather. In horse racing, surface conditions can vary greatly depending on weather conditions, specifically those due to precipitation. For example, for a dirt surface, a track can be rated as “fast” under dry conditions to “sloppy” under saturated conditions. A horse can under perform due to stress in humid, hot weather. In a manner analogous to a horse, a crop will perform differently under weather conditions, and will be negatively affected by extremes in heat or cold or by prolonged periods of wet or dry.

The importance of soil has been recognized since the earliest days of modern agriculture. Soil probes to determine bulk density and tests to determine fertility have become routine. In-ground moisture, temperature, and salinity sensors have become more popular with high value crops for tracking soil conditions during a growing season. It was not by coincidence that one of the first precision agricultural practices involving a global positioning system (GPS) was for “grid” soil samples. And it is not surprising that many growers either have an on-site weather station or subscribe to a service that provides daily updates and forecasts of weather for areas encompassing their farms. The handicapping of soil and weather data through frequent monitoring of the field environment is key for successful production decisions.

The Fantastic Fourth

The fourth variable on a farming form could be field scouting. In the horse racing analogy, scouting a field is like scouting a horse. Scouting a horse includes reviewing past performance against other horses of a similar age class, how many wins or places the horse had at a similar race track, length of race, and jockey, and whether the horse led from the start of a race or came from behind. In a similar manner, a field scout can determine how a crop performs in competition with pests or when stressed environmentally. Like a racing handicapper, a field scout will review records of pest occurrences in previous seasons and past frequencies of extreme weather events that could result in yield loss. The same scout would have good understanding of how a seed variety would perform in terms of its timing of phenological stages during a season, resistance to pests, tolerance to environmental stresses, and potential yield. Data in the form of past records, field study results, and past experience are necessary before a plan can be put together for an upcoming season’s crop production practices.

A potential fifth variable on a farming form could be the resources necessary to grow a crop. Resources are important to a horse as to a crop. A successful racing horse requires years of training by an expert, proper nutrition, and appropriate riding equipment. A successful crop requires resources in the form of equipment, fuel, seed, fertilizers, pesticides, other amendments, and labor. While all growers have a preseason plan in mind, the specific practices in the plan need to be fine-tuned as a season unfolds. Nearly everyone is familiar with the 4R maxim of “right source, right rate, right time, and right place” that is promoted by the International Plant Nutrition Institute for best management practices. Executing the four “rights” requires data on readiness of equipment, fuel stock, seed stores, fertilizer and pesticide inventories, and availability of personnel. It also requires a tactical coordination of these resources with respect to the stage of the crop and environmental conditions throughout a growing season. The status of resources and the coordination of their application during a season requires logistical data that must be continually updated with each management decision.

Depending on the crop and geography, other variables may be candidates for a farming form. In the end, variables that make the list must have readily available data. PrecisionAg.com and PrecisionAg Magazine focuses a lot on data and their usage among service providers in precision agriculture. As illustrated with the farming analog of a racing form, these data must be analyzed and “handicapped” to ensure a crop ends up with a first place finish at the end of a growing season.

Leave a Reply

Data Management Stories
Data ManagementAgGateway Grain Traceability Proof-of-Concept Seeks Industry Participation
January 15, 2018
AgGateway’s Precision Agriculture and Grain & Feed councils have issued a call for participation for a proof-of-concept initiative in AgGateway’s Read More
John-Deere-Cab-GPS
Data ManagementPrecision Ag Hardware and Software: A Little Off-Season Maintenance Goes A Long Way
January 10, 2018
All service technicians have heard this line. Most often when spring makes its anticipated return to our lives. It is Read More
Spray Drift
Data ManagementAg Data Lawyer Recaps Top 2017 Ag Tech Developments
December 28, 2017
It is here again–the end of another year. For me, this is always a good time to take a look Read More
forbes-agtech-summit
Data ManagementAgFunder.com Ranks 2017’s Largest Ag Tech Funding Rounds
December 28, 2017
It was an exciting year in farm technology involving a few high profile venture capital exits and some of the Read More
Trending Articles
Anez-Consulting-Paul-Anez-and-Michael-Dunn
Service ProvidersAnez Consulting: Focus On Fertility
January 9, 2018
Central Minnesota features variability aplenty when it comes to soil characteristics and topography, from flat, black expanses rich in organic Read More
Agrishow2017
Americas5 Best Ag Tech Shows in Brazil
January 8, 2018
Brazil continues to demonstrate its potential in agriculture. Several international companies are investing in our country because we have a Read More
Farmer and computer
Service ProvidersPrecision Agriculture Writers Wanted To Join Our Team in 2018
December 10, 2017
About The Opportunity: PrecisionAg.com is looking for people to join our team in 2018 and submit original content to our Read More
Harvested-Corn-Field-Clouds
Data ManagementWeather Services Advance Precision Agriculture
December 4, 2017
Some estimates suggest over half of growers’ activities are impacted by weather conditions, from field workability to fertility management to harvest Read More
Wheat-an-oats-Daniel-X-ONeil
Data ManagementWill Open-Source Finally Unlock Ag Technology’s Potential?
November 28, 2017
To Aaron Ault’s eyes, ag technology right now is something like a walled garden — not unlike the Microsoft of Read More
Africa/Middle EastPERSPECTIVE: Is Bayer’s Highly Anticipated xarvio App the Next Uber for Ag?
November 22, 2017
As many of our CropLife IRON readers might know, every summer at MAGIE we award the most popular product featured Read More
Latest News
center-pivot-irrigation-drop-sprinklers-on-corn
Precision IrrigationFinding Your Precision Ag Mindset
January 15, 2018
A precision mindset is the most important requirement for successful precision ag technology adoption. One of my first VRI (variable Read More
Drone-and-operator-Photo-courtesy-of-Kray-Technologies
DronesCrop Protection Application by Drone: A Q&A with Kr…
January 15, 2018
January is a busy month for agricultural companies. It’s a month that strong sales can set the mood for the Read More
Data ManagementAgGateway Grain Traceability Proof-of-Concept Seeks Ind…
January 15, 2018
AgGateway’s Precision Agriculture and Grain & Feed councils have issued a call for participation for a proof-of-concept initiative in AgGateway’s Read More
Corn-Planter
Grower Services & SolutionsCorn Planter: The Train of Consequences
January 11, 2018
It’s always planter season in our shop but now that harvest is done the corn planter is the next piece Read More
Robotics/Labor SaversSmart Ag Announces Driverless Tractor Automation Platfo…
January 11, 2018
An Iowa technology company has unlocked the tremendous potential for automation in agriculture by developing the first cloud-based platform for Read More
John-Deere-Cab-GPS
Data ManagementPrecision Ag Hardware and Software: A Little Off-Season…
January 10, 2018
All service technicians have heard this line. Most often when spring makes its anticipated return to our lives. It is Read More
Anez-Consulting-Paul-Anez-and-Michael-Dunn
Service ProvidersAnez Consulting: Focus On Fertility
January 9, 2018
Central Minnesota features variability aplenty when it comes to soil characteristics and topography, from flat, black expanses rich in organic Read More
Agrible
Grower Services & SolutionsAgrible to Launch Retailer Services in 2018
January 9, 2018
It’s a new year, which means new market challenges. Full service retailers are searching for ways to differentiate themselves and Read More
jeremy-speaking
Grower Services & SolutionsGrower and Precision Ag Services: Opportunities Lost
January 9, 2018
I often spend time with growers, talking about their operations, and the processes they go through each season to do Read More
Winters-Farming-farm-manager-Alex-Bergwerff-and-Ranch-Systems-marketing-and-business-development-manager-Hylon-Kaufmann
Precision IrrigationInside California Irrigation: Winters Farming
January 9, 2018
As many of us already know, almonds tend to get a bad rap for their water-use efficiency — or some Read More
Sentera software
DronesSentera Offering Elevation Data Mapping Via AgVault
January 9, 2018
Sentera announces the availability of elevation maps within the Sentera AgVault platform, offering agronomists, crop consultants, and growers additional field Read More
Industry NewsRaven, South Dakota State University Link Up: What You …
January 9, 2018
On Tuesday afternoon Raven and South Dakota State University (SDSU) held a press conference on the SDSU campus in Sioux Read More
Agrishow2017
Americas5 Best Ag Tech Shows in Brazil
January 8, 2018
Brazil continues to demonstrate its potential in agriculture. Several international companies are investing in our country because we have a Read More
Aarav-Unmanned-Systems-team
Asia12 Indian Agritech Startups to Watch Out For in 2018
January 3, 2018
Farming is a profession of hope. And India holds the record for the second-largest agricultural land in the world, with Read More
Amazone-Amaspot
Australia/New ZealandAmazone Set to Release Weed-Detecting Sprayer in Austra…
January 2, 2018
European farm machinery giant Amazone is set to release its UX trailed weed-detecting sprayer in Australia, which it says can Read More
drone-wheat-field
DronesAgricultural Drones: From Detection to Diagnosis
January 2, 2018
There is not a remote sensing platform that is innately better at all things: satellites, manned aircraft, and unmanned aerial Read More
Soybean Field
Tools & Smart EquipmentPrecision Ag Technology: Use It, Don’t Lose It in 2018
January 2, 2018
With the start of the New Year, I always find myself reflecting on the past year and identifying what worked Read More
Cory-Willness-featured-image
Service ProvidersGenerating Value From Boots-on-the-Ground Precision Ag
January 2, 2018
The flaghip product from CropPro Consulting, Naicam, Saskatchewan, may sound like part of a high stakes hostage situation. But SWAT Read More