Inside the Key Strategies For Selling Precision Ag Services

SDSU-drone
Dr. Aaron Franzen (holding drone) discusses the mechanics of an unmanned aerial system and the value of aerial imagery with precision ag students at South Dakota State University.

In its earliest manifestation, the motive for developing precision agriculture service was entirely pure. Agronomists knew that crops were responding variably across fields for a variety of reasons, and emerging technology was going to provide a pathway to understanding — and reacting to — the variability.

Georeferencing of fields, soil testing, fertility prescription writing, scouting, yield monitoring, and scorecarding quickly emerged as agronomists bolted on emerging technologies and worked hard to keep up with the massive inflow of data.

Of course, the wide range of technology and growing requirement for expertise was not going to come at no additional cost, so the question quickly emerged: “How can we do all this, demonstrate clear value, and get paid for the value we create?”

Some two decades later, for many retailers the pursuit of precision program-generated profitability persists.

Approaches To Value

If the struggle sounds like the one you face down every day, you’re not alone. As they say, “if it was easy, everyone would be doing it.” Many precision managers battle to create and capture value for their grower-customers, but there are a number of obstacles that keep us from reaching the Promised Land.

  • During times of tight and sometimes negative margins like we are presently experiencing in production agriculture, producers and retailers need to evaluate every line item and justify the value it brings to their operation.
  • We typically give new technologies a “free pass” while they are in their infancy phase. However, as these technologies mature and become mainstream they must prove their worth to both the buyer and the seller.
  • Precision agriculture services and technologies have predominately been given a pass as we let them evolve from novelty into a category production agriculture now relies upon to effectively operate and produce present-day yields.
  • The value of precision ag technologies and services varies widely based on multiple variables, including the following:
    • The role you play in the value chain– i.e., producer, retailer, agronomy services provider, equipment dealer, manufacturer, software provider, commodity sales, input provider, seed production, fertilizer producer, etc.
    • Geographic location
    • Type of crops grown
    • Farming practices (tillage model, crop rotation, etc.)
    • Size of operation
    • Skill sets of employees and customers
    • Business strategy — high volume and low margins vs. lower volume and high value of services provided.

Obstacles aside, all agricultural retailers in general are in the business of selling the commodities of chemicals, nutrients, and seed to regional producers. For the most part these are the same commodities their competitors are selling. So, precision ag technologies and services can differentiate a retailer’s products and services from that of their competitors. The key is in how they are packaged and sold to the grower.

Pricing Model Options

For the sake of simplicity, we’ll outline the four most common pricing model methods currently being deployed by retailers who offer precision programs in the table below:

Pricing Model Advantages and Benefits Disadvantages and Challenges
Bundled Per Acre
Flat per acre rate with all “precision services” offered by the retailer included in the plan.  
  • Ease of billing
  • Farmer knows cost up front
  • Separates customers into two separate groups (participating in precision program or not).
  • Allows for easier analysis of yield trends within each of the two groups.
  • Allows group data analysis to be presented to entire group in the program to improve production within the group.
  • Likely to create a closer relationship for all inputs with the grower (less shopping around).
  • Easier to build in a call center/service center fee.
  • Large upfront commitment for producer
  • Potential to be an expense that is cut during low profit margin years
  • Each additional service outside of package requires surcharge
  • Difficult to “dabble” with just a few acres.
  • Farmer usually must commit to all or none.
  • Machinery limitations of grower may not allow full implementation of program
  • Accurate data analysis requires trustworthiness of grower and operators to properly adjust/calibrate equipment
Per pass or service
Each pass across the field or individual service has a price associated with it.  
  • Able to charge a higher total price vs. bundled model due to less “sticker shock”
  • Allows producers to pick and choose their individual needs
  • Allows company to analyze margins of each individual service
  • Ease of entry/exit from use of specific services
  • Grower and retailer work together to develop best plan for each operation
  • Bookkeeping becomes more challenging as each service needs to be tracked separately.
  • Harder to prove benefits of the service as there is no “Large group” of producers doing same practices.
  • Requires higher effort from salesforce as each individual product or service must be “sold”
  • Easy for grower to say “not this year” on certain services
% of yield bump/gain
(example: a ten bushel/acre yield bump was added to a grower’s average and they share four of those bushels with their service provider)  
  • Places accountability with the service provider to deliver results.  “The saying put your money where your mouth is” applies here.  Grower is more likely to commit as it is obvious that they only pay if they receive a yield gain
  • Potential for higher adaptation by grower and producers
  • Keeps service provider in closer contact with grower throughout the year as their paycheck depends on the grower’s success!
  • This is a unique approach, sure to make conversation as farmers talk to farmers, making for self-advertisement.
  • Delayed collections as retailer must wait for harvest to be completed
  • Determining baseline yield establishments
  • Weather variability
  • Measurement of yield (yield monitor, grain cart, certified scale tickets?), Is a yield monitor calibrated by the grower accurate enough?
  • Determining a market price for the grain
  • Risk of negligible or no yield bump equates to no payment to service provider
  • May “discourage” growers to shoot for higher yields
  • No consideration for reduced inputs.
  • Model may not be sustainable long term
Per unit of product sold
Service is bundled with each unit of fertilizer, chemical, seed, etc.  
  • Ease of bookkeeping
  • Services buried within the price of a retailer’s commodities
  • Spreads the overhead cost of precision ag professionals and technologies over all customers
  • Encourages growers to cut back on inputs
  • Easier for competition to undercut a retailer’s price if grower doesn’t see value of buried service charges

As you can see, and as we’re sure you have experienced, each system has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, but retailers are not necessarily beholden to strictly one approach to value expression.

Douglas-Prairie
At left, Douglas Prairie, Ag and Biosystems Engineering instructor, works with Tyler Carda, a student in the Precision Ag program at SDSU, to assess the true cost of having equipment that is not performing to its full potential.

For example, one possible approach to consider would be a combination of the bundled and per-pass model. For example, a retailer could offer grower customers an “all-in” per acre plan, and for those who balk or would prefer a “get their feet wet” program allow them to pay on a per service or per pass system. Most of a retailer’s income may come from the “all in” customer who purchase more products from the retailer, delivers more grain, etc.

If obtaining more grain for your operation is of importance there are a couple of methods in which this model could benefit you. First is improved customer loyalty resulting in growers delivering a higher percentage of their bushels to a retailer’s grain operation. Second, growers should be growing more grain as result of a retailer’s precision ag service, hence they will have more grain to deliver.

Finally, you may be able to look to the future through the data and relationships you have built through your precision ag program, and identify which producers will be growing more grain in the future — and therefore have the potential to deliver more acres to your ag retail operation.

This is but one example — no one size fits all, and no method provides a complete solution. But understanding the potential directions available for your precision program, and objectively comparing the strengths and challenges of each system, are important for maximizing profits from your precision offerings.

Leave a Reply

Business Management Stories
Digital-Farming
Business Management7 Factors That Could Make or Break Digital Farming
April 13, 2018
Digital farming is the new technology genie – a genie that is now out of the bottle and cannot be Read More
aggateway
Business ManagementAgGateway Encourages Use of Standard Identifiers with AGIIS Subscription Promotion
April 11, 2018
AgGateway, the non-profit organization with the mission to promote and enable the industry’s transition to digital agriculture, is offering a Read More
InSiteDCM
Business ManagementDelivering on Ag Data Value
April 3, 2018
Bruce Baier is another deeply experienced precision agriculture manager who survived the early years of ag technology while riding the Read More
University-of-Georgia-photo-credit-USDA
Business Management25 Best Colleges for Precision Agriculture
March 21, 2018
Choosing the right college is a process. It’s one that I’m just now embarking on with my teenage daughter. Long Read More
Trending Articles
Farm-Storm-Clouds-Photo-Eden-Hills
Data ManagementThe Precipitation Problem in Agriculture
April 17, 2018
Precipitation is arguably the most important agricultural weather parameter, yet it is the most difficult variable to precisely measure. For Read More
SDSU-drone
Business ManagementInside the Key Strategies For Selling Precision Ag Services
April 13, 2018
In its earliest manifestation, the motive for developing precision agriculture service was entirely pure. Agronomists knew that crops were responding Read More
CROO Robotics’ automated strawberry harvester
Robotics/Labor SaversSpecialty Crops: Get in Gear Now for Agriculture’s Robotic Revolution
April 11, 2018
While the immigration debate rages on in Washington, DC, with little chance for reform in sight, the uncertain labor picture Read More
InSiteDCM
Business ManagementDelivering on Ag Data Value
April 3, 2018
Bruce Baier is another deeply experienced precision agriculture manager who survived the early years of ag technology while riding the Read More
University-of-Georgia-photo-credit-USDA
Business Management25 Best Colleges for Precision Agriculture
March 21, 2018
Choosing the right college is a process. It’s one that I’m just now embarking on with my teenage daughter. Long Read More
Farmer-tablet
Decision Support SoftwareOpinion: The Missing Link in Precision Agriculture
March 15, 2018
The agtech boom over the last two years is indeed astonishing. Farmers are becoming more open to new, emerging technologies Read More
Latest News
Finalists-teams-Syngenta-Crop-Challenge-in-Analytics
Data ManagementData-Driven Strategies and Machine Learning Shaping the…
April 26, 2018
Last week I attended the 2018 INFORMS Conference on Business Analytics & Operations Research in Baltimore, MD. Among the activities Read More
Sentera-FieldAgent
Industry NewsSentera, The Climate Corp. Partner to Enhance Agronomic…
April 24, 2018
Climate FieldView customers can now enjoy seamless integration of Sentera FieldAgent on-field sensor and analytics products with FieldView, as well Read More
Field Sprayer
Sensors/IoTHere’s What’s Working with the Internet of Things ̷…
April 24, 2018
With the advent of the Internet of Things (IoT), we are now seeing farmers use more wireless technologies to increase Read More
Case-Header-2
Industry NewsAustralian Company Offers On Combine Analysis Technolog…
April 24, 2018
Next Instruments is an Australian manufacturer of instrumentation for the grains and food industries. Over the last 5 years Next Read More
corn field
Industry NewsNutrient Ag Solutions Launching New Digital Farming Pla…
April 24, 2018
Nutrien’s retail division – soon to be rebranded as Nutrien Ag Solutions – has announced the launch of a new Read More
Industry NewsClimate Corp Announces 5 New FieldView Integrations
April 23, 2018
The Climate Corporation announced the addition of five industry-leading partners to The Climate Corporation’s Climate FieldView digital agriculture platform. The Read More
Laura_Crook_WinterWheat_Blackgrass_PrecisionAg
Industry NewsKansas Software Outfit Ag Developer Announces agX Integ…
April 23, 2018
Ag Developer, a Kansas based software development company, is simplifying grower/advisor communications by connecting to the agX Platform, according to Read More
field_in_back_1000_wd-featured-image
Industry NewsAyrstone Introduces High-Speed WiFi System for Farms
April 20, 2018
WiFi has become a necessity, and a proliferation of new WiFi devices have come to market for urban homes and Read More
Indian-Agriculture
AsiaIndian IoT Platform for Pre and Post Harvest Raises See…
April 19, 2018
Indian startup AgNext has raised an undisclosed seed round led by India-focused Agtech VC Omnivore Partners along with Singaporean angel Read More
Bayer-Forward-Farming
Industry NewsMaryland Farm Opens as Hub of Learning about Sustainabl…
April 19, 2018
Fourth-generation Maryland farmer Trey Hill measures the success of his operation not just by how many bushels of corn, soybeans, Read More
THRIVE
Industry NewsAgritech Startup Backers Announce New Corporate Partner…
April 18, 2018
Entering its fourth year, the THRIVE Venture & Innovation platform announced today the nine finalists and investment in its spring Read More
computer-in-field
EventsFinding Our Way in the Business of Precision Agricultur…
April 17, 2018
Service providers are the essential link between precision agriculture products and practices and the farmers who are increasingly relying on Read More
Farm-Storm-Clouds-Photo-Eden-Hills
Data ManagementThe Precipitation Problem in Agriculture
April 17, 2018
Precipitation is arguably the most important agricultural weather parameter, yet it is the most difficult variable to precisely measure. For Read More
Digital-Farming
Business Management7 Factors That Could Make or Break Digital Farming
April 13, 2018
Digital farming is the new technology genie – a genie that is now out of the bottle and cannot be Read More
SDSU-drone
Business ManagementInside the Key Strategies For Selling Precision Ag Serv…
April 13, 2018
In its earliest manifestation, the motive for developing precision agriculture service was entirely pure. Agronomists knew that crops were responding Read More
Facebook-phone
Data ManagementWhat Lessons Can the Ag Industry Learn from the Faceboo…
April 12, 2018
Today, a seemingly endless amount of ag data flows from growers’ fields into a host of technology platforms. It is Read More
DronesWhen High Value Crops Meet Inaccessible Areas: How Dron…
April 12, 2018
Avocados are one of the few crops in Chile that can economically be commercially cultivated on hills. On one hand Read More
Almond-trees-blooming
Sensors/IoTWhy Virtual Sensors Could Save California’s At-Ri…
April 12, 2018
To say that the Golden State can lay claim to the title of king of almonds might be an understatement. Read More