On-Farm Trials in Brazil: The Way to Improve Agronomic Knowledge

The idea of using on-farm trials to gather data about the performance of any crop input has been in place even before the advent of modern science. Farmers tend to test anything new on small portions of their fields and compare with their common practices before adopting a new practice on their whole farm.

This practice may work well for some crop inputs and some farmers, for example, when only two treatments need to be compared, the fields are relatively homogenous, and the new treatment yields 10% more than the farmer’s common practice. In this situation, even if small errors in the trial planning, data collection, or data analysis occur, the experiment conclusion will be the same and the farmer will be pleased in the next year when he sees the results of applying the winner treatment to the whole farm. However, as agricultural production systems get more complex, more detailed methods are needed.

The number of inputs applied during a crop season increases every year. This is driven by the occurrence of new pests and diseases, the availability of new fertilizer sources, and the advances in plant physiology. This more intensive way of farming has been responsible for the yield increases attained in the last decades, but has also raised production costs. Translating this fact to the context of this article, it means that the yield difference accountable by each crop input is smaller and therefore a higher level of accuracy in the whole experimentation process must be attained to secure that the right conclusions can be drawn.

Statistically speaking, this means more levels of treatments are needed to account for interactions, and more replications to account for field spatial variability and reduce uncertainties. This imposes some challenges for farmers, which has forced most of the agronomy experimentation to move from fields to the more controlled environments of research facilities. With the advent of precision agriculture and the development of new agricultural machines, some of the challenges of large scale on-farm trials were overcome and the interest in this subject was renewed. But this happened more than 20 years ago and this important tool for improving agronomic knowledge and the whole production system is not widely adopted yet. So, what makes me think that the next 20 years will be completely different in that context?

It is worth mentioning some previous articles posted on PrecisionAg.com, which report USDA funding the University of Illinois research that focuses on using precision technology in on-farm field trials to enable data-intensive fertilizer management, and Syngenta investing in Premier Crop Systems to accelerate the development of Enhanced Learning Blocks. The great interest among public and private sectors to advance this topic is a good indicator of its importance and poses a fundamental step to make it accessible to more farmers.

Another important aspect that is evolving is data sharing across networks of farmers. The results obtained in projects like Farmers Business Network and FarmLogs Research Network are examples of what can be obtained with the collaboration of farmers. In these circumstances, the large number of observations in different fields can compensate for the errors associated with data collection. This is specifically true when production systems are similar and standard protocols can be easily implemented.

One of the reasons precision agriculture was thought to be a game changer in the use of on-farm trials more than 20 years ago was because it would be much more simple and cheaper to implement treatments, keep track of everything during the crop season, and analyze the results. You would just need to make a variable rate prescription in seconds, then collect the yield map data with the combine while harvesting, and then draw the conclusions.

In practice, a lot of time needed to be spent planning the treatment locations, accounting for machine capabilities, converting data to an acceptable format, checking and calibrating sensors, dealing with lost data, converting yield data, cleaning the raw data, and analyzing the results. Some of these laborious and time-consuming tasks have been automated by precision agriculture software and the new digital agriculture platforms we have seen in the last years, but there is still room for a lot of improvements and generalizations. One important issue related to this problem is data standardization and ease of access, and some important developments towards resolving it having been made in the last months by the AgGateway initiative.

During a presentation I made last month at the Seminar of Precision Agriculture, which was held in Piracicaba – SP, on the topic of improving agronomic recommendations in management zones, the audience questions made it clear that software and methodologies to analyze this data is still a major barrier to the widespread adoption of on-farm trials in Brazil. At Smart Agri we have been providing consultancy for farmers, service providers, and crop input companies on the use of on-farm trials. Although we can overcome the challenges mentioned above with skilled professionals, the quality of data collection has been the main issue. Most of the data we get are from large farms, and when you have a fleet of combines, it is much more difficult to assure data accuracy. Another important thing to mention is the diversity of production systems and the intensive land use, ranging from one to three crops a year in the same area. The previous crop is likely to influence the results, and the hurry to seed the next crop will be the priority, not the data collection.

Although there are many obstacles to the adoption of on-farm trials, we are excited with the potential observed in some successful histories. The maps shown are an example of this, illustrating the use of on-farm trials to evaluate cotton response to nitrogen application. Cotton is one important crop in Brazil, which is mainly cultivated by “high tech” farmers. The objective of these trials is to compensate for spatial and temporal variations in the optimum N rate to be applied. The total N amount planned is usually split in four applications: 10% at seeding, 30% at 20 days after seeding (DAS), 30% at 40 DAS, and 30% at 60 DAS. We use a fixed rate at seeding, and implement the on-farm trials at 20 DAS, using variable rate based on historical data for the rest of the field. In the photo below, each square plot has about 2 ha and the whole field has 700 ha. The trials are replicated in each management zone.

On-Farm-Trials-Brazil
On-farm trials are used to evaluate cotton response to topdress nitrogen application in Brazil. The applied rate at 20 days after seeding (left) and a satellite image of the crop response at 40 days after seeding (right).

We then start to monitor crop development and adjust the next two applications based on the crop response. Although it may seem similar to the use of reference strips to determine nitrogen fertilizer requirements in other crops such as corn and wheat, there is a main difference. The relationship between cotton vigor and cotton yield is not linear. Because of that, the rate to be applied must not limit cotton yield, but it is likely to still limit cotton vegetative development, which means that some crop scouting is needed to validate the model. We are also investing in some technologies similar to the ones in use for plant phenotyping to make data collection fully automated. With this use of on-farm trials we can get cotton yield improvements of 5% to 10% and nitrogen savings of 20% to 30%. Future technological developments will allow the size of the plots to be reduced and the number of replications to be increased, generating more robust results.

Leave a Reply to Pedro Magalhães Cancel reply

One comment on “On-Farm Trials in Brazil: The Way to Improve Agronomic Knowledge

Americas Stories
AmericasMFA Precision Head Talks Precision Ag, Cover Crops at 2018 4R Summit
June 18, 2018
Although implicit to anyone that spends a good chunk of their career in agriculture, the link between advanced precision technology Read More
David-Perry-featured-image
AmericasIndigo Touts ‘New Approach to Agricultural R&D’
June 13, 2018
Indigo, the Boston-based microbial crop technology startup that has raised more than $400 million, announced it is expanding its research Read More
Drone-exhbitor-at-Drone-Show
AmericasDroneShow Highlights UAV Technology in Latin America
June 4, 2018
Editor’s note: The DroneShow Latin America is an annual trade fair hosted by MundoGEO, a media and communications company founded Read More
AmericasNAAA Issues Drone Pilot Reminder: Watch Out For Aerial Applicators
May 31, 2018
With more than 1 million UAVs registered with the FAA, it is vitally important for UAV operators to be aware Read More
Trending Articles
JDandPessl
Sensors/IoTJohn Deere, Pessl Instruments Team Up to Create Opportunities
June 18, 2018
John Deere is best known for its line of tractors, combines, sprayers, and implements. However, in an effort to help Read More
Matt-Waits-featured
Decision Support SoftwareSST’s Matt Waits: Innovative Data Solutions Key to Transforming Global Agriculture
May 31, 2018
Proagrica, part of RELX Group, earlier this year acquired U.S.-based precision agriculture solutions company, SST Software, in a move set Read More
InfoAg ConferenceThe InfoAg Conference Offers Early Bird Registration Discount
May 24, 2018
Since 1995, The InfoAg Conference has been the premier event for discussion and advancement of precision agriculture. The event, organized Read More
Ernie-Chappell-Screenshot
EventsEFC Systems Sponsorship Demonstrates Commitment to Continuing Education for Retail Dealerships
May 16, 2018
Enterprise software manufacturer EFC Systems, scholarship sponsor of the inaugural PrecisionAg® Professional Accelerator professional development conference this June in Brookings, Read More
EventsMeister Media Debuts Growing Innovations
May 10, 2018
As a service provider, you and your grower customers probably can agree on this much: While innovation abounds in agriculture, Read More
UCANR_booth_Food_IT_forum
EventsForum Calling All Innovators of Agriculture Technology
May 2, 2018
The challenges that come with feeding the world continue to grow. Luckily, so do advances in information technology that are Read More
Latest News
Imagery/SensingIntelinAir, TerrAvion Partner on Ultra High Resolution …
June 21, 2018
IntelinAir has partnered with TerrAvion to deliver what it is calling a “best in class imagery solution” to joint customers Read More
Industry NewsRaven Launching CR12 Field Computer in Europe this Week
June 19, 2018
Raven Industries announced the release of a new, larger field computer: the CR12. Utilizing the same functionality as the CR7 Read More
dropcopter
DronesNew York Apple Orchard Claims World First in Pollinatio…
June 18, 2018
Beak & Skiff Apple Orchard in LaFayette, NY, is the first orchard in the world to use drones to pollinate Read More
Farmer with iPad
Decision Support SoftwareAgrian Enhances Field Scouting App
June 18, 2018
Agrian has added a new feature to its robust field scouting app – a pest trap counting solution. The new Read More
AmericasMFA Precision Head Talks Precision Ag, Cover Crops at 2…
June 18, 2018
Although implicit to anyone that spends a good chunk of their career in agriculture, the link between advanced precision technology Read More
Iron Man
UncategorizedAgFunder News: Forget Self-Driving Tractors; Agricultur…
June 18, 2018
Marvel’s Iron Man suit might seem an unlikely source of inspiration for growers, writes Joseph Byrum on AgFunderNews.com. Once the Read More
Soil-Corn-plants-field
Data ManagementRemote Soil-Sensed Management Zones Help Increase Crop …
June 18, 2018
Accurate prescription maps are essential for effective variable rate technology (VRT) fertilizer application. Grid soil sampling is frequently used to Read More
JDandPessl
Sensors/IoTJohn Deere, Pessl Instruments Team Up to Create Opportu…
June 18, 2018
John Deere is best known for its line of tractors, combines, sprayers, and implements. However, in an effort to help Read More
computer-in-field
Business Management3 Questions to Ask When Looking for Your First Job in P…
June 18, 2018
Let me begin this column by extending my congratulations to all of my fellow students who have just graduated – Read More
Robotics/Labor SaversStine Seed Plunks Down $5 Million on Smart Ag’s D…
June 14, 2018
Stine Seed Farm has invested $5 million in Smart Ag Inc., an Iowa technology firm that has developed a full Read More
David-Perry-featured-image
AmericasIndigo Touts ‘New Approach to Agricultural R&…
June 13, 2018
Indigo, the Boston-based microbial crop technology startup that has raised more than $400 million, announced it is expanding its research Read More
Ag Drone
EventsAgTech Conference of the South Dedicated to Innovation,…
June 12, 2018
Join current and emerging agtech business leaders and investors at the AgTech Conference of the South, a premiere conference dedicated Read More
Munckhof Machinefabriek equipment
EuropeEurope: Precision Farming at Heart of Munckhof Deal
June 11, 2018
One of Europe’s oldest suppliers of machinery used in fruit production, the Dutch firm Munckhof Machinefabriek, has been purchased by Read More
Australian-Farmers
Australia/New ZealandCrunching the Ag-Tech Numbers Saves Time for Australian…
June 5, 2018
Time management is key on the Walker family’s farm, where a mix between cropping, commercial sheep and two studs means Read More
Drone-exhbitor-at-Drone-Show
AmericasDroneShow Highlights UAV Technology in Latin America
June 4, 2018
Editor’s note: The DroneShow Latin America is an annual trade fair hosted by MundoGEO, a media and communications company founded Read More
Imagery/SensingImagery in Agriculture: Time for a Reality Check
June 4, 2018
Where do I begin….I’ve been dealing with imagery in agriculture since I was 10 when my dad started Satshot. At Read More
AmericasNAAA Issues Drone Pilot Reminder: Watch Out For Aerial …
May 31, 2018
With more than 1 million UAVs registered with the FAA, it is vitally important for UAV operators to be aware Read More
Matt-Waits-featured
Decision Support SoftwareSST’s Matt Waits: Innovative Data Solutions Key t…
May 31, 2018
Proagrica, part of RELX Group, earlier this year acquired U.S.-based precision agriculture solutions company, SST Software, in a move set Read More