Nitrogen: The Key to Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions

pathways_precisionWith today’s public policy focused on reducing greenhouse gas emissions, farmers can play a key role in making this happen. In fact, by optimizing the nitrogen fertilizer, a farmer’s contribution can come with the side benefit of increased yield and higher profit.

As with every industry, farming contributes to the production of various greenhouse gases. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change says that agriculture is responsible for a fifth of greenhouse gas emissions, which primarily come from the nitrous oxide produced as soil microbes digest the available nitrogen source. Nitrous oxide is listed among the most potent of greenhouse gases.

Soil will, of course, emit nitrous oxide without any help from farming, but the process is greatly enhanced with the application of nitrogen fertilizer—particularly when there is more nitrogen applied than the plants can absorb.

That is where precision ag can play a role in reducing agriculture’s impact on greenhouse gases by limiting the nitrogen rate. But the big question is, how can that be done while at the same time increasing yield?

Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge

Nitrogen is the limiting nutrient factor of corn yields. Every year, farmers struggle with balancing the need to meet yield targets without over-applying nitrogen fertilizer. Agronomists have spent decades studying the nitrogen response curve to find the optimal balance of nitrogen fertilizer. Because yield increases become negligible beyond a certain nitrogen rate, farmers are advised to apply that rate on the curve to maximize their profits (see the point labeled N0 in the chart). Beyond this point, additional money spent on nitrogen fertilizer will not increase net revenue from additional yield.

So to reach our ultimate goal of reducing nitrogen while increasing yield and profits, we have to shift the nitrogen response curve, which is a job well suited to precision agriculture. The power of more data and better analysis gives farmers a better understanding of the land while enhancing the ability to tackle highly variable situations.

In the short term, field mapping makes precise, variable rate fertilizer application possible. The basic system involves attaching sensors to equipment to measure seeding rates and planter metrics in the spring along with yield and moisture in the fall. Software packages like FieldView provide a simple and intuitive interface for all the data captured in farm operations.

These data are needed to determine the variable rates of nitrogen fertilizer for each individual section of a field. Used in conjunction with autosteering and autoguidance, variable rate application is easy and inexpensive and should reduce the amount of nitrogen fertilizer used in total. Using less nitrogen, of course, saves money.

Having a detailed record of farm activity will be vital to understanding how a particular field reacts to different practices and weather conditions, and having better understanding enables better decisions. While there is no demonstrable link yet between yield improvement and field mapping, the cost savings should be enough to justify the investment.

More importantly, better timing of fertilizer placement is essential to the ultimate goal of reducing nitrogen and raising yields in an industry that tends to overuse nitrogen. Farmers traditionally take advantage of downtime in the fall to place fertilizer. Extreme weather is less likely in the fall than in the spring, and any delay in fertilizer placement would create a crunch when it came time to planting seeds. Unfortunately, the traditional fall placement means extra fertilizer has to be used to account for any runoff that may occur in the months before planting.

The latest, high-tech fertilizers enable much more flexibility. New formulations improve the nitrogen uptake by plants, allowing fertilizers to be placed in the spring and “sidedressed” (meaning it can be applied at key stages of plant growth when it is most needed). When the timing is right, the plant absorbs the nutrients without excessive nitrous oxide leakage into the atmosphere.

Weather is always the biggest obstacle to proper timing. Flash floods can quickly wash away recently placed fertilizer, depriving plants of needed nutrients. For this reason, springtime sidedress placement of fertilizer is most effective in dry, irrigated regions, where such extreme weather is rare.

Another downside is that farmers will need to have enough labor on hand to place fertilizer and seeds in the same time frame. Of course, none of these methods will do any good if a farmer, out of an abundance of caution, decides to overapply fertilizer anyway to ensure the plants are not undernourished.

These short-term improvements provide a strong foundation for a long-term solution that will more fully deliver on the promise of higher yield, lower cost and an improved environmental profile. The key to unlocking the best performance is going to be the development of a seed that optimizes nitrogen fertilizer usage.

The most promising approach to achieve this is to improve high-population planting by developing dwarf hybrids and narrow-row planting. While this remains a distant goal, it is possible to see a few paths forward.

Corn yields have climbed by 45 percent in the past three decades, but the plant yield per seed has remained flat over the same period. This suggests that population increases are driving yield gains, which makes sense as genetically engineered seeds, crop protection chemicals and fertilizers reduce the stresses plants face, allowing for expanded populations.

Unfortunately, there is a population density at which yields level off because of escalating intra-row competition between plants. Once this point is reached, there are two ways to break through the yield ceiling. The first is the development of dwarf corn hybrids. University of Maryland biologist Burkhard Schulz grew an experimental dwarf mutant corn plant that had all the nutrition of a full-size corn plant in a much more compact form, standing just a few feet high. In the words of Schulz, the kernel yield you get from the plant is more or less unchanged, but the biomass of the entire plant is reduced by more than half.”

Small size is an ideal trait for a high-population environment, since it allows more stalks to be grown in a smaller area without competition. More importantly, the dwarf corn may require fewer inputs for the same yield, as a longer stalk requires more sunlight, nutrients and water. Although these plants are still under development and may never be fully developed, they represent a very promising way to improve the yield-population dilemma.

Planting in narrow rows is another possible avenue for breaking through the yield ceiling. Most research in the past 15 years suggests that narrow rows have negligible yield advantages in high-population environments, but this may be due to the use of seeds that are not optimized for this environment. With different genetic engineering, narrow-row planting could improve nitrogen efficiency and increase yields. More research needs to be conducted to understand the effectiveness of narrow-row planting.

Time will tell which solution will deliver higher yields, greater profits and a more benign environmental profile. But it is clear that precision ag will play a key role in improving nitrogen efficiency. The good news is that improvements are possible now that they make financial sense for growers.

Byrum is Senior R&D and Strategic Marketing Executive in Life Sciences – Global Product Development, Innovation and Delivery at Syngenta. Byrum will present the session, “Solving Big Problems: Innovation Through Open Collaboration” at the PrecisionAg Vision Conference on October 19. For more information visit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One comment on “Nitrogen: The Key to Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions

  1. Garst had the shorty hybrid lineup 15 years ago. The yields were in line with other properly placed hybrids given the field conditions. Interesting to see the concept come back around.

Best Practices Stories
Corn Field
Best PracticesPrecision Agriculture And The Not-So-Obvious Factors Affecting Production Decisions
October 5, 2016
Crop production is a seasonal enterprise during which day-to-day decisions are made with a goal of high yield and profitability. Read More
Best PracticesPrecision Ag’s Role in Getting Nitrogen Right For a Better Environment
September 2, 2016
Scientists can be forgiven for thinking that when they come up with optimized methods for accomplishing some task, end-users will Read More
Dave Swain (left), precision ag specialist, at Southern States
Best PracticesSouthern States: Management Zones Help Harness Field Variability
September 1, 2016
Not all fields are alike. Many different variables affect how your crop performs in a single field, so blanket-treatment of Read More
Philippines rice field
Best PracticesPrecision Agriculture Key To Sustainability In India
August 8, 2016
The sustainability of the agriculture production system in India appears to be under threat due to over-exploitation of natural resources, Read More
Trending Articles
GrowersCotton And Precision Ag: Playing MoneyBoll
October 5, 2016
Much like baseball, farming has always been illuminated by data. Take, for example, Babe Ruth. Would we have realized how Read More
Planet Labs satellite imagery
DataAerial Imagery: Choose Your Own Adventure
October 5, 2016
The aerial imagery industry is in a rather strange place currently. Which of the three options (satellite, manned aircraft, or Read More
BusinessPrassack Advisors Drafts Weather Data Report
October 4, 2016
Agriculture technology solutions are rapidly evolving from basic data management tools to true decision support systems. Granular weather data is Read More
Ian Yule, ISPA
ResearchLeading Ag Technology Researcher Appointed ISPA President
September 26, 2016
Massey University’s Professor Ian Yule, one of the world’s leading agri-tech researchers, has been voted president of the International Society Read More
Business2016 Farm Science Review: Talkin’ New Products, Education and Big Data
September 21, 2016
The Ohio State University’s Farm Science Review has become an annual rite of fall for Buckeye State growers, retailers and Read More
Mitchell Technical Institute students with drone
IntegratorsMTI Precision Ag Students Use Drone Technology
September 19, 2016
After weeks of sitting in the classroom, several Mitchell Technical Institute students were able to spend a few hours outside Read More
Latest News
Corn Field
GrowersCorn Growers On Big Plots Are Most Tech-Savvy Of Farmer…
October 20, 2016
U.S. corn farmers are proving themselves to be quick learners, writes Mario Parker on Growers producing the grain on Read More
GrowersVIDEO: Jim Case Multi-Hybrid Cropping System Update
October 19, 2016
We revisit with Central Ohio grower Jim Case and farm manager Nate Long (featured in the February 2016 Precision Ag Read More
EquipmentCEMA President: CAP Reform Should Encourage Farmers To …
October 18, 2016
European CAP reform should include measures to help farmers invest in digital technology and equipment, according to the President of Read More
AgBot16 Challenge
ResearchUK Field To Be Farmed Exclusively By Robots
October 18, 2016
Harper Adams University staff, supported and led by precision farming specialist Precision Decisions, are attempting to grow and harvest a Read More
Wade Barnes Farmers Edge using FarmCommand
DataP&H, Farmers Edge Form Partnership To Boost Canadia…
October 18, 2016
Parrish and Heimbecker Ltd. (P&H) have announced it has partnered with Farmers Edge, a global leader in precision agriculture and Read More
Mike Duncan drone
ResearchDemonstrations Highlight Farming’s Future
October 18, 2016
Hovering above the grapes growing in the experimental field behind Niagara College’s Wine Visitor and Education Centre, the drone represents Read More
Grower using MyJohnDeere with tablet
BusinessDeere Issues Statement on DOJ Lawsuit Blocking Precisio…
October 13, 2016
The agricultural industry will benefit from Deere’s acquisition of Precision Planting LLC (“Precision Planting”) through faster and better innovation focused Read More
John Deere Close-up
BusinessDeere-Ag Leader Planter Tech Agreement Adds Choices; Co…
October 12, 2016
In a move which could serve to improve the prospects of the Deere-Precision Planting deal currently under challenge by the Read More
Ag Drone
BusinessDroneDeploy Publishes Drone Mapping Directory
October 12, 2016
DroneDeploy, a cloud-based drone software platform, today unveiled the Drone Mapping Directory, a drone mapping marketplace to connect businesses with Read More
GuidanceNovAtel Launches RTK ASSIST Service
October 11, 2016
Today at Intergeo, NovAtel introduced its RTK ASSIST service. RTK ASSIST is a subscription-based service that provides users with satellite-delivered Read More
DataUPDATE: Checking In on Jim Case’s Multi-Hybrid Ohio Har…
October 10, 2016
YOU VERY WELL may remember central Ohio grower Jim Case from a cover story in Precision Ag Special Reports that Read More
BusinessAgGateway Conference To Focus On Business, Technical As…
October 7, 2016
Business and technical executives seeking to advance their companies’ electronic connections with trading partners are encouraged to attend this year’s Read More
Ag Data Transparent logo
DataGROWMARK System Recognized For Ag Data Transparency
October 6, 2016
GROWMARK is the first agricultural cooperative system and complete farm supply and service organization to earn the “Ag Data Transparent” Read More
Tim Norris
Think Data FirstThink Data First: Harvest Edition
October 5, 2016
There may be no other time of the year when good data management practices are as crucial as during fall Read More
Case IH Autonomous concept vehicle
EquipmentMajor Progress In Harvest Iron
October 5, 2016
Not to be outdone by advances in precision on the planter, spreader, and sprayer ends of the business, combine manufacturers Read More
GrowersCotton And Precision Ag: Playing MoneyBoll
October 5, 2016
Much like baseball, farming has always been illuminated by data. Take, for example, Babe Ruth. Would we have realized how Read More
Planet Labs satellite imagery
DataAerial Imagery: Choose Your Own Adventure
October 5, 2016
The aerial imagery industry is in a rather strange place currently. Which of the three options (satellite, manned aircraft, or Read More
Corn Field
Best PracticesPrecision Agriculture And The Not-So-Obvious Factors Af…
October 5, 2016
Crop production is a seasonal enterprise during which day-to-day decisions are made with a goal of high yield and profitability. Read More