On-Farm Research Basics

If you’ve looked at your yield monitor read out and thought, “You know, I could use this to do some field research,” you’re on the right track. “Anyone can do on-farm research,” says Dan Anderson, on-farm research coordinator at the University of Illinois. “Yield monitors make it even easier.”

But while it may be easy to measure yield differences with the monitor, do these differences have anything to do with the question you’re researching? Maybe…maybe not. It all depends on whether your study is designed to yield valid results.

If you’re going to make input decisions based on the results — your results must be valid. That is, results that point to the input factors that really made a difference. And that takes some understanding of field research methods and statistics.

But don’t turn the page yet. While a full description of on-farm research takes more explanation than this article can provide, it’s not like trying to master brain surgery. There are practical books and accessible experts ready to help you.

What we can do in this article is give you a general idea of what constitutes good on-farm research — and how to formulate an action plan for your own research efforts.

The effort will be worth it, says Rick Exner, farming systems coordinator for the Practical Farmers of Iowa and an extension associate at Iowa State University.

“While you don’t want to make serious management decisions based on one year’s worth of data, with your own on-farm research you’ll have information you can’t get from any other source.”

What Makes Good On-Farm Research

Joe Gednalske, manager of product development for Cenex/Land O’Lakes Agronomy, describes a basic on-farm “pseudo-research” dilemma: “Farmer used one herbicide on one field, used a different herbicide on another field,” Gednalske explains. “Got different yields. Was it the herbicide? Who knows? He got a difference in yield, but what other things were different? You just don’t know.”

So the key to good research is isolating what you’re testing from other factors that can affect the outcome. In a crop field, where conditions vary from foot to foot, that’s no simple task. But it’s possible.

“Even if you have a very uniform field and do everything exactly the same throughout the field, you’ll still get variation,” explains Anderson. “Like on a yield map — every 2 feet it’s a different yield. So if you see differences, you don’t know if that’s because of natural variations in the field or the treatments.”

There are ways to compensate for natural variations. If this is your first try at on-farm research, make it easy on yourself, and look for a fairly uniform field, suggets John Oolman, director of precision farming research for Agri-Growth Inc., Hollandale, Minn.

Look For Uniformity

“Pick out a field that doesn’t have a history of uneven manure application, doesn’t have any old field boundaries in the middle and doesn’t have large elevation changes,” Oolman says. “Don’t use the boundaries of the field — the headlands — because they’re not typical of the rest of the field, either.”

Look at a yield map or search your memory (and maybe the memories of your elders) to assure that the field is fairly uniform. “We’ve had some surprises,” he says. “You’ll find spots in a field that are real high in fertility and soil quality, and the 40-year-old farmers won’t know why. But Grandpa will say, ‘Happy Jack had an old hog farm there.’ You’ll still see high fertility leels around old homesteads and barns that have been gone for 50 years.”

To further factor out variation, do each treatment more than one time. “This is called replication,” Anderson says. “Replication is the key. There’s a mathematical way to account for the natural variations — the background noise — and separate that from the treatment effect, if there is one.

“For on-farm work, six replications of each plot generally provides the optimum results,” Anderson explains. “Any accuracy you gain with more than six reps is probably not worth the extra expense.”

Replication Filters Out Variations

According to Anderson, to make at least six replications of each plot, or treatment alternative, a commonly used experimental design for on-farm research is what’s called the randomized complete block.

Each block contains one set of all the plots, or treatments being compared, in random order. A block represents one replication, and blocks are placed side-by-side. A diagram for a simple two-treatment experiment is illustrated in “The Big Picture.”

The replicated block design is useful in accounting for and filtering out variation in agricultural soils, Anderson notes. That’s why splitting a 40-acre field, treating one side one way and the other side another way, yields dubious research information. However, this can provide a memorable visual comparison.

“We call that a demonstration research plot,” Anderson says. “Sure, you can tell obvious differences, like if one side of the field is dead and the other is growing, or if there’s a 50-bushel yield difference. But most studies don’t generate differences that dramatic.”

Gednalske makes another practical suggestion for your first ventures into on-farm research. “Look at as few variables as possible — just compare A to B, don’t go further and try to compare C, D and E,” he recommends. “The analysis is too complex. And when you limit the variation in the inputs, you’ll be more likely to get what the universities would consider good replication.”

Keep Equipment In Mind

Plot size is determined by your equipment size. “If a farmer has an eight-row planter and a four-row combine, for example, I’ll recommend that each plot be eight rows wide. It’s a convenient size to plant and harvest,” Anderson says.

Interestingly, Anderson recommends that only the center rows of the plots be harvested and this data used for comparison. So in the example above, he would direct the farmer to harvest and measure the center four rows and leave two rows on each side of the plot as buffers.

“This is because treatments on the edge rows of each plot can bleed into each other and confuse the effects,” Anderson explains. “This is particularly true for herbicide comparisons.”

Plot length is typically determined for convenience’s sake, usually to the end of the field to avoid having to turn around in the middle of the field. But plots don’t have to be this long, Anderson says. “Smaller plots will contain less natural variation.” he explains. “They can be 100 feet long and provide reliable data and cut down considerably on the amount of land used.”

Oolman notes an alternative that farmers sometimes use to compare seed selection is to stirp-plant the field, loading one type of seed in half the planter, another type in the other side. Although this does not randomize the plots, it can be an acceptable method “if you do 25 or 30 strips like this,” Oolman says.

Just take care not to favor one side over the other. “Make sure you’re planting at the same depth,” he notes. Also ensure that your planter is calibrated for the correct seed size and shape on each side.

Your Action Plan

With diligence and knowledge, good on-farm research is well within your reach.

If you’d like to pursue this topic further, here are some good resources to tap into: “On-Farm Research Guidebook” by Dan Anderson, available by writing: Department of Agricultural Economiccs, University of Illinois, 305 Mumford Hall, 1301 W. Gregory Drive, Urbana, IL 61801.

On-farm research coordinators are available through the agricultural economics department at the University of Illinois and the agronomy department at Iowa State University.

Many extension ag agents can provide research guidance and direct you to other resources at your land grant university.

Contact your farm supply dealer or the company rep from your herbicide or seed supplier. They can put you in touch with the research departments of your input suppliers, who may be able to provide advice, guidance and possibly some tangible support.

Editor’s note: This article first appeared in the March-April 1997 issue of PrecisionAg Illustrated.

Leave a Reply

PrecisionAg Institute Stories
Wade-Barnes
Excellence AwardsBuilt By Agronomists: 2017 Award Of Excellence Winner Wade Barnes on the Making of Farmers Edge
August 2, 2017
Farmers Edge President And CEO Wade Barnes reflects on the process of building his company, shortly after receiving the Crop Adviser/Entrepreneur Award during the InfoAg Conference in July. Read More
InfoAg 2015
Events2017 Awards of Excellence Winners Announced
July 18, 2017
PrecisionAg Institute is pleased to announce its Awards of Excellence winners for 2017. Honorees of this year’s prestigious award are Read More
Rod Weimer and Paul Schrimpf
Excellence AwardsPast Recipients Of The PrecisionAg Awards Of Excellence
July 18, 2017
Since 2007, the PrecisionAg Insititute has sponsored the annual Awards of Excellence program. Here's a list of the past winners. Read More
Excellence AwardsDr. Harold van Es Named 2017 Educator/Researcher of the Year
July 1, 2017
Dr. Harold van Es is Professor of Soil Science at Cornell University. He established Cornell’s Computational Agriculture Initiative, which focused Read More
Trending Articles
Agri-AFC-cotton-baler
Business ManagementBringing a Southern Sensibility to Precision Agriculture
August 7, 2017
Amy Winstead considers herself blessed to have gotten in on the ground floor of precision ag adoption in the Southeast. Read More
Sensors/IoT2017 Yield Monitor Calibration Checklist — Part I
August 4, 2017
With fall harvest a few weeks away for most of the country, ag service providers from every walk of life Read More
Wade-Barnes
Excellence AwardsBuilt By Agronomists: 2017 Award Of Excellence Winner Wade Barnes on the Making of Farmers Edge
August 2, 2017
Farmers Edge President And CEO Wade Barnes reflects on the process of building his company, shortly after receiving the Crop Adviser/Entrepreneur Award during the InfoAg Conference in July. Read More
Data ManagementInfoAg 2017 Recap: Service Providers Take Center Stage
July 28, 2017
As I sit here and ponder just what it was that we all experienced last week, off the top of Read More
Resistant-weeds-in-Brazil
InternationalUsing Precision Agriculture to Control Herbicide-Resistant Weeds in Brazil
July 24, 2017
The occurrence of weeds in agricultural fields of grain and fiber production has caused losses to farmers for a long Read More
Yield Data Image
Data ManagementYield Data: More Than a Pretty Picture
July 13, 2017
It is mid-July, which, for the Australian cotton industry, means that picking is still going on for some growers. A Read More
Latest News
Data ManagementBeck’s Builds Out ‘Freemium’ FMIS Off…
August 17, 2017
Beck’s today announced the release of several new tools available in their precision farming service, FARMserver, which enhances farmers’ ability Read More
Israel-Irrigation-system-featured-image
InternationalIsraeli Precision Ag Companies Lead in Water Use Effici…
August 16, 2017
In the last week, AgriHub, formed by farmers and consultants from Brazil, visited 10 Israeli agribusiness companies, including the Ministry Read More
Gregoire-tractor
ProfessionalsMechanization Key to the Future of Vineyard Management
August 15, 2017
Precision technology moves at different speeds across different segments of agriculture. For example, technologies like curve compensation, precision spraying, and Read More
Area-of-Interest-Web-Soil-Survey-screenshot
Data ManagementSignificant Updates Made to SoilWeb, Web Soil Survey Pr…
August 15, 2017
Agronomic professionals and technicians dealing with precision farming must understand the soils within the field before writing effective prescriptions.  A Read More
Univ.-of-Illlinois-Palmer-in-soybean1
Business ManagementOpinion: How to Leverage Precision Agriculture to Launc…
August 14, 2017
To continue where my last article left off (which you can check out here), a precision ag company that specializes Read More
Industry NewsFarm Dog Inks Non-Funded Cooperative Agreement with USD…
August 14, 2017
Farm Dog, a pest and disease management platform for growers and agronomists, has entered into a Non-Funded Cooperative Agreement (NFCA) Read More
Lisa-Prassack-Photo-Credit-Weekly-Times-Now
InternationalAgtech: What the Umbrella Term Really Means
August 10, 2017
Acclerator, incubator, start-up, connectivity — the buzzwords of the digital age can be clear as, well, mud, writes Alex Sampson Read More
Spray Drift
Data ManagementJanzen: Data to Play Key Role in Sorting Out Dicamba Di…
August 10, 2017
You would have to live under a rock to not have heard about farmers’ issues with dicamba this growing season. Read More
New-Zealand-Precision-Ag-Tour
InternationalNew Zealand Study Tour to Demonstrate Recent Advances i…
August 10, 2017
If you’re interested in an intense, week-long immersion in the use of high-tech products and practices in New Zealand agriculture, Read More
Data ManagementDuPont Acquires Ag Tech Startup Granular for $300 Milli…
August 9, 2017
DuPont announced that it has signed a definitive agreement to acquire San Francisco-based Granular, Inc., a provider of software and Read More
EventsSDSU Prof to lead Profit-Focused Panel at Upcoming Inno…
August 9, 2017
Convening a day prior to this summer’s Farm Progress Show at the I Hotel in Champaign, IL (about an hour’s Read More
AGCO White planter 9800VE
ProfessionalsAGCO Crop Tour 2017 Features Precision Planting Add-Ons
August 8, 2017
Higher yields and greater returns are the ultimate goals for crop producers. To help corn growers better understand the role Read More
Corn
Business ManagementCrop Pro Insurance Closes $8 Million in Series A Fundin…
August 8, 2017
Crop Pro Insurance today announced the close of an $8 million Series A round of financing co-led by top agriculture Read More
Agri-AFC-cotton-baler
Business ManagementBringing a Southern Sensibility to Precision Agricultur…
August 7, 2017
Amy Winstead considers herself blessed to have gotten in on the ground floor of precision ag adoption in the Southeast. Read More
Satshot imagery
Imagery/SensingImagery in Agriculture: Some Sage Advice
August 6, 2017
SatShot President Lanny Faleide has been a fixture on the remote imagery scene for as long as about anyone still Read More
Blue-River-See-Spray-technology
ProfessionalsHow Blue River’s See & Spray Technology Could Chang…
August 5, 2017
The blistering West Texas heat rocketing towards triple digits, the affable cotton grower trudged across his dusty field and approached Read More
Grower Services & Solutions2017 Yield Monitor Calibration Checklist — Part II
August 4, 2017
(EDITOR’S NOTE: This is Part II of Tim Norris’ Yield Monitor Calibration checklist, Part I of which was published in Read More
Sensors/IoT2017 Yield Monitor Calibration Checklist — Part I
August 4, 2017
With fall harvest a few weeks away for most of the country, ag service providers from every walk of life Read More