Judge Smacks Down FAA Authority Over UAS Operations (UPDATED)

The friendly skies may finally be opening up for small UAVs in precision agriculture (as longs as they remain below 400 feet).

Yesterday, National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) administrative judge Patrick G. Geraghty granted a motion to dismiss in a case that will likely set a new legal precedent, striking down current FAA regulatory authority over UAS operations by ruling against two FAA Memoranda (2005’s Memorandum AFS-400 UAS Policy 05-01 and a 2008 revision) and a 2007 FAA Notice OF Policy (07-01) as “not meeting the criteria for valid legislative rule making.”

Geraghty states in his ruling: “Significantly, both Memoranda specifically eschew any regulatory authority…stating respectively that ‘this policy is not meant as a substitute for any regulatory process’…As policy statements of an agency are not binding upon the general public these policy Memoranda cannot be, and are not, found as establishing a valid rule for classifying a model aircraft as a UAS.”

By arguing that the fixed wing UAV he piloted on Oct. 17, 2011, falls under the FAA definition of a “model aircraft” and that there is “absence of a valid rule for application of authority over model aircraft flight operations,” Raphael Pirker and his legal team exploited a longstanding loophole that allows model aircraft hobbyists to evade the FAA’s regulatory reach.

“Complainant (FAA) has historically, in their policy notices, modified the term ‘aircraft’ by prefixing the word ‘model’ to distinguish the device/contrivance being considered…FAA has distinguished model aircraft as a class excluded from the regulatory and statutory definitions (of aircraft),” ruled Geraghty.

As a result of his finding, Geraghty ordered Pirker’s Motion to Dismiss hereby granted and the FAA’s order of a $10,000 assessment against Pirker vacated.

AUVSI Responds

Today, Michael Toscano, president & CEO of the Association for Unmanned Vehicle Systems International (AUVSI), released the following statement on the National Transportation Safety Board’s Pirker Decision:

“We are reviewing the decision very carefully and we have also been in touch with the FAA to discuss its implications and the agency’s response. Our paramount concern is safety. We must ensure the commercial use of UAS takes place in a safe and responsible manner, whenever commercial use occurs. The decision also underscores the immediate need for a regulatory framework for small UAS.”

Steve Hogan, a Tallahassee, FL-based attorney well-versed in FAA regulations and an instructor of “Drone Law” at the Unmanned Vehicle University, responded to an email seeking comment on the implications of the decision. “I have read the opinion, and there is still a lot to think about. The best I can say is that this is a step in the right direction. The FAA has a variety of options now, including an appeal and emergency rulemaking. I would expect that the FAA will do something soon.”

If appealed, the case will reportedly be heard before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia.

UPDATE: FAA Responds, Appeal Grounds All Commercial Flights For Now

From an FAA news release dated March 7, 2014: The Federal Aviation Administration today issued a notice appealing a decision by an NTSB Administrative Law Judge in the civil penalty case, Huerta v. Pirker.

“The FAA is appealing the decision of an NTSB Administrative Law Judge to the full National Transportation Safety Board, which has the effect of staying the decision until the Board rules. The agency is concerned that this decision could impact the safe operation of the national airspace system and the safety of people and property on the ground.”

Topics:

Leave a Reply

Equipment Stories

EquipmentValmont Acquires Majority Stake In AgSense
August 26, 2014
Valmont Industries, a leading global provider of engineered products and services for infrastructure and mechanized irrigation equipment for agriculture, has acquired a majority interest in South Dakota-based AgSense. Read More
EquipmentCase IH, Precision Planting Let Producers Customize Their Planters
August 26, 2014
Producers can choose to add any or all Precision Planting components to their new Case IH Early Riser planter, depending on which they feel will deliver the greatest value to their operation. Read More
EquipmentKinze, Raven Develop Touchscreen Monitor For 4900 Series Planter
July 23, 2014
Kinze Manufacturing announces a partnership with Raven Industries to develop a standalone monitor solution for the Kinze 4900 series planter. Read More
EquipmentMU Professor: Drones Have Major Potential In Agriculture
July 18, 2014
Despite strict federal rules regulating drones for agricultural usage, University of Missouri Professor Bill Wiebold believes it’s important to plan for the future. Read More

Trending Articles

PrecisionAg Institute1 On 1 With Paul Schrimpf: John Deere’s Chris Batdorf
September 15, 2014
Chris Batdorf of John Deere talks with PrecisionAg Executive Editor Paul Schrimpf about the latest with the company’s FarmSight strategy, how John Deere is responding to growers’ concerns about data privacy, new mobile technologies the company is currently working on and John Deere’s philosophy on collaborating with industry partners. Read More
Variable Rate2014 Precision Ag Top 5 Technologies
September 2, 2014
The top precision agriculture technologies didn’t change in the past year, according to experts. What has changed, however, is their order of activity. Read More
PrecisionAg Institute1 On 1 With Paul Schrimpf: The Climate Corp.’s John Jansen
August 29, 2014
John Jansen of The Climate Corp. talks with PrecisionAg Executive Editor Paul Schrimpf about how the company’s technology platform has transformed into a full host of software, hardware and analytic solutions. Read More
EquipmentDeere Dealer Meeting: Machinery Improvements Boost Precision
August 23, 2014
John Deere's array of new releases and product improvements were punctuated with efficiency upgrades that should allow for improved use of precision practices. Read More
Data5 Key Precision Farming Trends Showcased At The InfoAg Conference
July 30, 2014
No other event in agriculture quite captures the latest trends in precision farming like The InfoAg Conference. Find out what was hot at this year's event in our photo gallery. Read More
EquipmentNew Soil Sampling System Debuts At InfoAg
July 28, 2014
North Carolina grower Allan Baucom has what he feels is a better idea for automating soil sampling, and it’s on Read More

Latest News

HardwarePlantBeat: Monitor Plant Growth Real-Time
September 17, 2014
Israel-based Phytech brought its real-time plant growth monitoring system to St. Louis to debut at InfoAg 2014. Read More
PrecisionAg InstituteBeltway Session To Share Precision Ag Benefits With Reg…
September 17, 2014
The Coalition for the Advancement of Precision Agriculture (CAPA) will host its inaugural event, the Precision Ag Forum, Thursday, September Read More
PrecisionAg Institute1 On 1 With Paul Schrimpf: John Deere’s Chris Bat…
September 15, 2014
Chris Batdorf of John Deere talks with PrecisionAg Executive Editor Paul Schrimpf about the latest with the company’s FarmSight strategy, how John Deere is responding to growers’ concerns about data privacy, new mobile technologies the company is currently working on and John Deere’s philosophy on collaborating with industry partners. Read More
GuidanceTopcon Appoints New Customer Support Lead
September 10, 2014
Topcon Precision Agriculture (TPA) introduces Robert Lindgren as the new director of customer support for the global marketplace. Read More
DataCargill Launches Planting Data Software
September 9, 2014
The tool, called NextField DataRx, will compete with data-analysis services from companies including Monsanto Co. and DuPont Co. Read More
PrecisionAg Institute1 On 1 With Paul Schrimpf: Wilbur-Ellis’ Matt Wilson
September 9, 2014
Matt Wilson of Wilbur-Ellis talks with PrecisionAg Executive Editor Paul Schrimpf about the latest with the company’s AgVerdict software, how Wilbur-Ellis addresses data privacy concerns with growers and why fulfilling regulatory requirements is becoming increasingly important. Read More
PrecisionAg InstituteIndustry Stakeholders Form New Precision Coalition
September 8, 2014
The Coalition for the Advancement of Precision Agriculture (CAPA) today announces its official launch and upcoming Precision Ag Forum, taking place Sept. 18 in Washington, DC. Read More
Equipment2014 Farm Science Review: Decade Long OSU, Purdue Partn…
September 8, 2014
The 52nd annual Farm Science Review marks the 10th anniversary of Ohio State University’s partnership with Purdue University and Purdue Extension. Read More
PrecisionAg Institute1 On 1 With Paul Schrimpf: WinField’s Dave Gebhardt
September 4, 2014
Dave Gebhardt of WinField talks with PrecisionAg Executive Editor Paul Schrimpf about how the company’s Answer Plot program provides insight into precision agriculture, how the Web-based R7 Tool has evolved since its launch in 2011 and how WinField and The Climate Corp. are working together with data science. Read More
Variable RateRoot Demand Irrigation Introduced At Husker Harvest Day…
September 3, 2014
Co-developed by Valmont Irrigation and DuPont, Root Demand Irrigation is launching a subsurface irrigation method to help growers improve underperforming acres using less water, energy and time. Read More
DataDuPont Pioneer Expands Encirca Yield Input Management O…
September 3, 2014
A new grower pilot program will expand on the input management offerings in the recently launched Encirca Yield services platform to include phosphorous and potassium management. Read More
Awards2014 Awards Of Excellence Winners: Champions Of Precisi…
September 2, 2014
The 2014 Class of PrecisionAg Awards of Excellence recipients have spent their careers working to improve precision practices, increase adoption and put best practices in place on the ground. Read More
Variable Rate2014 Precision Ag Top 5 Technologies
September 2, 2014
The top precision agriculture technologies didn’t change in the past year, according to experts. What has changed, however, is their order of activity. Read More
SoftwareThe New AgVerdict Is In
September 2, 2014
Wilbur-Ellis heard you. A powerful new version of AgVerdict precision software — for desktop and mobile — offers intuitiveness and ease across more than 300 crops. Read More
PrecisionAg Institute1 On 1 With Paul Schrimpf: The Climate Corp.’s John J…
August 29, 2014
John Jansen of The Climate Corp. talks with PrecisionAg Executive Editor Paul Schrimpf about how the company’s technology platform has transformed into a full host of software, hardware and analytic solutions. Read More
DataThe Climate Corporation Announces Acreage Milestone, Ne…
August 28, 2014
The Climate Corporation has announced a new acreage milestone achieved by its Climate Basic service, as well as a new price point for Climate Pro subscribers. Read More
SteeringOutback Guidance Introduces Next Generation Auto Steer …
August 27, 2014
Outback Guidance has introduced three new precision auto steer systems: the eDriveXD, eDriveXC and eDriveESI. Read More
GuidanceTrimble Conducting Demonstrations Of NextSwath End Of R…
August 26, 2014
Trimble is conducting live demonstrations of its cutting-edge NextSwath end of row turn technology at the Farm Progress Show in Boone, IA. Read More