Has The Term “Precision Ag” Run Its Course?

It’s something that has come up a number of times during my 15-year career as purveyor of ag technology coverage. Al McQuinn, the CEO of Ag-Chem Equipment who financed the finishing touches on what would become Soilection technology in the 1990s, would share his opinion on it with anyone who would listen.

While I won’t attempt to fashion a direct quote, it went something like this: “I don’t like the term ‘precision agriculture.’ What we’re really doing is ‘site-specific’ agriculture, applying technology and best practices to the variations of individual fields.”

It was not a terminology battle he was going to win … in my humble opinion, because “precision” is a more marketable word. And it’s not like the word doesn’t apply at all. When we use technology on the farm, it is indeed for the purpose of being more precise about what we apply and how we apply it.

And the term has served us well as a way to identify improved practices and technology adoption over the past two decades. But there seems to be a growing call for an evolution to a different term for the “movement.” I think there are a few reasons for that.

First, nearly every grower in the US can claim to be using some measure of technology, be it auto steering, boom section control, variable-rate application, wireless data transfer … are all these farmers now “precision farmers?” In my mind the answer is ‘no,’ they need to be doing more than  that.

Second, with so many pieces of precision hardware out there collecting so much data, the emphasis is shifting from the big screens and shiny rigs to, “what do I do with all this information?” This is great, because it’s what manufacturers and consultants have been wanting for years – a grower who’s ready to take the next step.

Which gets us back to the term ‘precision.’ Growers, retailers and consultants seem to perceive it as meaning everything and nothing at the same time.

We decided to do a little informal survey in this eNewsletter last week, and the responses were interesting. Nearly 40% of respondents consider the term ‘precision’ to be misleading, asserting that we need another name. Just over 30% feel that the term is not a true reflection of the “movement” but at this point, it’s the best we have. The other 30% feel that ‘precision’ is a fair and accurate description.

Personally, even though I have “skin in the game” as the lead content guy at PrecisionAg.com,  I lean towards it not truly capturing what’s going on in ag technology today. In part, I think it’s because I’ve been in it so long, and I know that things are evolving toward data, and that technology is increasingly being integrated (as to become more invisible) over time, eventually becoming standard practice on the farm. But I still see value in retaining a specific identity for best practices in ag technology, at least for now.

I’ve been gravitating toward the term “smart agriculture” myself, but I’m interested in what you have to say. Please share some comments with me and our other readers in the comment area below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

11 comments on “Has The Term “Precision Ag” Run Its Course?

  1. I agree with you Paul, I think a lot of us that have been around over the last 15+ years have an affinity for the term Precision Farming, however these days the various types of technology falling in that bucket tend to suggest it maybe time to update our terminology. I’m not sure what the new phrase should be but maybe we should ask someone from generation Z. It’s kind of like our baby is all grown up now…

  2. Paul,

    I like Al McQuinn’s ‘site-specific’ as well as ‘precision’ and , your term, ‘smart.’ I teach “Agriculture and the Environment” where we look at all the ways agriculture, people and the environment interact. Two terms I see there used to describe the advanced agriculture we see today are ‘modern’ and ‘scientific.’
    Patrick

  3. I agree Paul – there’s a big difference between guidance and telematics and it’s increasingly inappropriate to throw them into the same catch-all “precision” bucket. It happens in other industries too though – IBM and Hewlett-Packard are still coded as a “tech” stocks alongside Facebook and Google – go figure. I like your “Smart Ag” tag – hope it picks up steam!

  4. Precision ag is the right term, but over-used since the 90’s. Real “precision ag” is just beginning.

    The driver is “big data”, which is accumulated by sensors, and sensors are getting cheap. For example, watch how cheap RTK GPS/GNSS will get in the next 3 years. Tremendous amounts of high-precision data will be at our fingertips. Software is needed to process that data and provide information to make high-quality decisions. That’s where the rubber meets the road.

    Maybe precision ag will be renamed like virtual apps were renamed cloud apps, but don’t let the name fool you. It doesn’t matter what you call it, precision ag is entering a new era.

  5. I had similar discussions with Al McQuinn, and generally agreed with him that “site specific” was a better term for what we were doing, especially related to fertilizer management. The technologies have now expanded to where many others are part of the bundle. It includes GPS, GIS, genetics, remote sensing, data management, sensors, guidance, communications, etc, etc. Most fit “site-specific; most fit precision (maybe still not as well); most are evolving and becoming integrated into just plain “agriculture”. We have been using the term “InfoAg” to cover the technology and the information management—but it probably isn’t a very accurate descriptor. “Precision” has been so widely adopted that it serves as a good link to all of these components. Maybe we will find and adopt a better term some day, but for now I can accept “precision” as a term that most people relate to. My main concern is that we keep on doing it, regardless of what we call it. We are just beginning to realize the potential impact on agriculture and where we are headed in the future.

  6. Technology Innovations in Agriculture (Tech-No AG)…
    Site-specific, soil-specific, crop specific management practices continue to change and evolve as new innovations….usually technology oriented….are incorporated into our crop production practices tool box.

  7. Other things that are Smart these days, as in Smart Cities, are more passive entities that benefit from sensors and systems than agriculture. Smart has some connotations that neglect the long history of modernizations that have improved efficiency, and it may offend individual farmers that have been doing smart things for some time. Scientific Agriculture acknowledges all the important research that has improved the practice, but again it’s a focus away from the individual farmer, placing emphasis on research and technology. Site-specific is a more neutral and inclusive term between researchers and technologists and the individual farmers, and it doesn’t lose sight of the land where the methods and the technology are applied.

  8. Although I did not participate in your survey I have for years been uncomfortable with the Precision Agriculture term.

    I had put down several combinations of words but usually came up with a lengthy pharse rather than a concise – descriptive term. Something I might be able to live with is Advanced Science Agriculture.

    Sorry, I don’t go for “Smart Agriculture”

    Thanks for your continued coverage.

    Roland Schirman
    Columbia Co Extension – Retired

  9. Paul
    Hi. I believe Precision Agriculture is the right term and I (and generally the rest of the world) generally asdociate any farming practice that uses GPS as Precision Ag. There are some exceptions.
    The academic boffins (who I was one of when I did my PhD Almost 20yrs ago) started on the ‘site specific’ application of inputs angle but I feel that is just a subcomponent of Precision Ag. The largest application of GPS has actually been in the auto steer market. It allows more precise farming operations that has lead to a wide range of benefits. It is not site specific farming but it is definitely a part of precision farming. At OptiSurface.com we are using GPS to improve landforming/grading. It’s not site specific application of inputs but definitely part of Precision Ag. I feel ‘smart ag’ is too vague.

  10. Paul,
    Having been involved in Precision Ag since it’s inception way back in the very early 1990s I tend to agree with Dr. Reetz who has seen it all. Back in the days when we protected our laptops with egg crate foam inside a plastic milk crate mounted on the front of a 4 wheeler with bungy cords. Not to mention how difficult it was to view the computer screens until you were jolted back into reality by a sink hole or a rut in the field. Back when we were using Dos operating systems on our laptops not Windows or whatever else is out there today. We weren’t to concerned about what we called it. I agree with Harold call it what you want just keep doing it. We have seen tremendous advances in precision ag in the last 25 years perhaps we should think of it as precise agriculture.

  11. Thanks for all the comments, lots to think about … and about as much consensus as there is around the office. Bottom line is, I’m glad there’s a lot of interest around the topic. We are in moving forward and there’s a bright future ahead.

Business Stories
Buhler Versatile HQ cab
BusinessThe State Of Precision Ag In 2016
December 7, 2016
There’s no denying that precision technologies and practices are more vibrant than ever. Elsewhere on this site, you will find Read More
BusinessFarmobile Details New AGCO Distribution Deal
December 6, 2016
Farmobile today announced a strategic partnership with AGCO, a worldwide manufacturer and distributor of agricultural equipment. The agreement will allow Read More
DataSentera Honored With Startup Award Of 2016 By Minnesota High Tech Association
December 1, 2016
The Minnesota High Tech Association (MHTA) recently recognized Sentera as the 2016 Tekne Startup Award recipient. The MHTA Tekne Awards Read More
Fall corn
BusinessInsecticide of the Future? Robotic Tanks With Lasers to Kill Pests
November 22, 2016
*Article Notes: This monthly column takes some crazy sounding ideas and applies them to the field of Ag Tech. The Read More
Trending Articles
Farmers Edge Truck
DataFarmers Edge, Trotter Fertilizer Form Partnership To Enhance VRT Programs
November 29, 2016
Farmers Edge, a global leader in precision agriculture and independent data management solutions, has partnered with Trotter Fertilizer, Nebraska’s foremost Read More
Kinze 4900 Multi-Hybrid Concept Planter
Business ManagementKinze Fights Deere, Feds To Block Release Of Trade Secrets
November 22, 2016
An antitrust lawsuit intended to block a small-scale deal between agricultural giants John Deere and Monsanto is putting an Iowa Read More
BusinessClimate Corp. Acquires European FMIS Company
November 21, 2016
Today, The Climate Corp., a subsidiary of Monsanto Co., announced the acquisition of VitalFields, a European farm management software company Read More
USDA UAV
Hort TechHigh-Tech Agriculture Continues To Reap Rewards For Farmers
November 11, 2016
Just like a smartphone helps users learn, communicate and make important decisions, smart technology — known as precision agriculture — Read More
BusinessTrimble Launches New FMIS Platform
November 7, 2016
Trimble announced today that it is consolidating three of its agriculture software products — Connected Farm, Farm Works Software and Read More
Grower Services & SolutionsGrower Groups Encourage Implementation Of AgGateway’s ADAPT For Precision Ag
November 2, 2016
A dozen leading U.S. grower organizations are hailing the collaborative efforts that led to the new AgGateway ADAPT framework for Read More
Latest News
BASF Maglis Grower Tablet
Business ManagementPrecision Farming Forecast: 4 Challenges, Opportunities…
December 7, 2016
Opportunities and challenges. They are the yin and yang of the business world. It could easily be argued that, out Read More
GVM E-Series cab
Ag Tech GlobalGlobalization And Precision Agriculture
December 7, 2016
Globalization has taken on a negative connotation in some circles in the U.S. in recent months. The lightning rod for Read More
Buhler Versatile HQ cab
BusinessThe State Of Precision Ag In 2016
December 7, 2016
There’s no denying that precision technologies and practices are more vibrant than ever. Elsewhere on this site, you will find Read More
BusinessFarmobile Details New AGCO Distribution Deal
December 6, 2016
Farmobile today announced a strategic partnership with AGCO, a worldwide manufacturer and distributor of agricultural equipment. The agreement will allow Read More
Hort TechSol Chip Launches Autonomous, Wireless Solar Tag for Sm…
December 6, 2016
Sol Chip, a provider of Internet of Things (IoT) systems and energy harvesting solutions, today announced the introduction of its Read More
TechnologyAgGateway Announces 2017 Board Of Directors And Leaders…
December 2, 2016
AgGateway has announced its leadership for the coming year, including the directors of its new Strategic Board and Operational Board, Read More
DataSentera Honored With Startup Award Of 2016 By Minnesota…
December 1, 2016
The Minnesota High Tech Association (MHTA) recently recognized Sentera as the 2016 Tekne Startup Award recipient. The MHTA Tekne Awards Read More
AGCO AgControl
TechnologyPrecision Ag Technology: Rate Control For The Times
December 1, 2016
It’s not surprising that the need for more economical, effective application is driving the demand for the latest rate controllers Read More
Farmers Edge Truck
DataFarmers Edge, Trotter Fertilizer Form Partnership To En…
November 29, 2016
Farmers Edge, a global leader in precision agriculture and independent data management solutions, has partnered with Trotter Fertilizer, Nebraska’s foremost Read More
Fall corn
BusinessInsecticide of the Future? Robotic Tanks With Lasers to…
November 22, 2016
*Article Notes: This monthly column takes some crazy sounding ideas and applies them to the field of Ag Tech. The Read More
Topcon X30 Console in cab
Sensors/IoTIoT The Focus Of New Topcon Partnership
November 22, 2016
Topcon Agriculture and SDF plan to enter into a non-exclusive long-term partnership agreement. This latest arrangement of Topcon with a Read More
Kinze 4900 Multi-Hybrid Concept Planter
Business ManagementKinze Fights Deere, Feds To Block Release Of Trade Secr…
November 22, 2016
An antitrust lawsuit intended to block a small-scale deal between agricultural giants John Deere and Monsanto is putting an Iowa Read More
BusinessClimate Corp. Acquires European FMIS Company
November 21, 2016
Today, The Climate Corp., a subsidiary of Monsanto Co., announced the acquisition of VitalFields, a European farm management software company Read More
BusinessFarmobile Releases Mobile Data Visualization Dashboard
November 17, 2016
Farmobile today announced an EFR Dashboard, a real-time dashboard that helps farmers visualize their field data and derive insights to Read More
Southern States
Best PracticesSouthern States: 5 Tips for Variable-Rate Seeding Succe…
November 15, 2016
Success comes from taking advantage of every opportunity you can. One technique used in precision farming, called variable rate seeding, Read More
USDA UAV
Hort TechHigh-Tech Agriculture Continues To Reap Rewards For Far…
November 11, 2016
Just like a smartphone helps users learn, communicate and make important decisions, smart technology — known as precision agriculture — Read More
THRIVE
BusinessCall For Ag Tech Startups: Apply To THRIVE’s Open…
November 10, 2016
THRIVE is looking for high growth ag tech companies with an in-market solution that are positioned to scale. The top 50 Read More
EquipmentJohn Deere Launching New Operations Center Apps, Mappin…
November 10, 2016
In an effort to enhance the functionality, ease-of-use and overall value of John Deere Operations Center to producers, John Deere Read More